Secrets Beneath the Limestone: The Haunted Legacy of Dodge City’s Home of Stone

Send us a text

A limestone mansion built to defy the prairie became a vessel for sorrow—and then a sanctuary. We take you inside Dodge City’s Home of Stone, from John Mueller’s audacious rise and the black walnut staircase that flaunted prosperity, to the winter they called the White Death that buried a cattle empire under ice. Amid ruin, another story took hold: Caroline’s quiet grief, a nursery that never warmed, a rocking chair that swayed without wind, and a whisper that sounded like a child who didn’t get to grow up.

When the Schmidts moved in, the house learned new rhythms—electric light, hot bread, children’s laughter—until a visiting boy tumbled down the staircase and said another child pushed him. Instead of fleeing, Elizabeth Schmidt opened the town’s memory, reading county ledgers and finding the Mueller graves that numbers can’t account for. Elma saw the silent boy in the wavering lamplight, pointing to the nursery, to his heart, and out across the endless plains—a pantomime of loss that didn’t need words.

The answer wasn’t force; it was recognition. In the basement, a trunk with faded initials held a small carved wooden horse, smooth from a child’s hands. Placed on the parlor mantel—the warm center of the home—the toy changed the house’s weather. The chill lifted. Doors stilled. What remained felt like a guardian more than a ghost. Across decades, the Home of Stone became a living museum of Dodge City’s true legacy: not just gun smoke and cattle drives, but the durable courage of pioneer mothers and the quiet rituals that heal places.

If this story moved you, follow the show, share it with a friend who loves haunted history, and leave a review telling us the object you’d place on your mantel to honor a forgotten story.

Support the show

If you'd like to buy one or more of our fully illustrated dime novel publications, you can click the link I've included.