Police Stories: The Rookie Years! A Tale of Two Kidnappings!

Send a text

In this episode of the Cops and Writers Podcast bonus series, retired Milwaukee Police Sergeant Patrick O'Donnell reads Chapter 33, "A Tale of Two Kidnappings," from his upcoming book:

Police Stories: The Rookie Years - True Crime, Chaos, & Life as a Big City Cop

With the Nancy Guthrie case dominating headlines, this chapter reveals what kidnapping calls are really like for cops—and the difference between what you see on TV and what actually happens on the streets.

Most kidnapping calls are bullshit. But when they're real, every cop drops everything.

The first story: One of Patrick's first nights riding solo. A "kidnapping" call that turned out to be a domestic dispute, with an unfortunate twist.

The second story: A real kidnapping. A mother duct-taped to a chair, beaten unconscious by her ex in a crack cocaine-fueled rage. Her five-year-old son is missing. Every cop on the shift came together. They weren't going home until they got that child back.

All stories are real. Names and locations have been changed where necessary.

🎧 This episode includes:

• Nancy Guthrie case context - "search, not a rescue."
• Patrick's first solo kidnapping call as a rookie
• The real kidnapping: Woman beaten unconscious, five-year-old son taken
• Hitting every crack house in the district
• Good news: The kidnapper dropped the kid off at Grandma's house
• "He didn't have the stomach for being a dad. Five-year-olds are a lot of work."
• Suspect arrested in Memphis, brought back to Milwaukee
• When it's real, every cop drops everything - "We weren't going home until we got that child back."

📘 About the Book:
Police Stories: The Rookie Years - True Crime, Chaos, & Life as a Big City Cop is a true crime memoir chronicling Patrick O'Donnell's early career as a big city cop during Milwaukee's crack wars in the 1990s.

Book Launch: Coming sooner than you think - stay tuned!
Book Update: Pre-orders are LIVE on Amazon. The book is currently a #1 New Release in Biographies of Law Enforcement.

🔗 Pre-order now for $3.99 (price goes up after launch): Search "Police Stories Patrick O'Donnell" on Amazon or check the link below.

📧 Contact Patrick:
Email: [e-mail]
Website: copsandwriters.com
Facebook Group: Cops and Writers

👍 If this story stuck with you:
Subscribe, leave a review, and share with someone who wants to know what real kidnapping investigations look like—not the TV version.

🎙️ Next week: Back to regular programming with a guest interview.

New chapters from the book continue every Wednesday night.

Visit the Cops & Writers Website!

Sonnet 4.5

Support the show