Send us a text

Natalie Wood's death remains a mystery to this day. Sarah and Casey discuss the mysterious circumstances surrounding the day she died.

Support the show

Send us a text

In December, 2000, a young father and husband went hunting one morning in Florida and never returned. It took 18 years, but when it was discovered what truly happened to him, it was a tough pill to swallow.

Source:

Mr. & Mrs. Murder on Hulu

Support the show

Send us a text

Join Casey & Sarah as they discuss the case of Lynn Stomps. When Jerry Stomps goes missing and his wife is found by a bridge, police fear the worse, But, is the culprit inside the Stomps home?

Killer Grannies

Season 1, Episode 4

Streamed on Hulu

Support the show

Send us a text

Join Casey and Sarah as they discuss the case of Brandon Johnson, who's controlling behavior was brought to light thanks to his two ex wives and their podcast.

Source:

Don't Date Brandon on Paramount Plus

Support the show

Send us a text

We had to re-record (thanks Riverside), Join Casey, Sarah, Husband Derek, and Cousin Celeste as they discuss the case of Kelly-Anne Bates.

The Case of Kelly Ann Bates

Source: Prime

Britain’s Darkest Taboos

Season 4

Episodes 12

Can be Streamed on: Prime

Support the show

Send us a text

We have questions for Derek! Tune in for another unhinged episode.

Support the show

Send us a text

Today's originally scheduled episode was supposed to be about Kelly-Anne Bates, but due to technical difficulties, we will have to re-record it. In the meantime, enjoy this replay of "Wait, He's From England?"

Happy Monday, ya'll!

Support the show

Send us a text

Join Casey, Sarah, Husband Derek, and Friend Celeste as we discuss everything that happened this week.

I apologize about the sound! There was a button I didn't press and did my best to fix it, if it sounds like I'm (Casey) is yelling.

Support the show