Leaving The Fold, Finding Ourselves

Send us Fan Mail

What happens when the story that once held your whole life together starts to crack? We open up about growing up Mormon, the rush of certainty that came with believing we had the “full truth,” and the quiet costs that trailed behind it—guilt, perfection chasing, and a subtle sense of superiority we didn’t know we carried. Then we trace the messy, human process of walking away: the grief, the questions that wouldn’t sit still, and the surprising ways love, purpose, and identity rebuilt themselves once the script was gone.

We talk candidly about rules and worthiness culture—no coffee, strict dating standards, and the constant self-audit that shaped our teens and early marriage. We also share moments that once felt undeniably miraculous: priesthood blessings, sudden healings, and the power of collective faith. As we compared those stories with what we saw in other traditions, we found patterns that look a lot like expectation, community energy, and the inner capacity to change. Rather than dismiss the sacred, we widen it: if transformation shows up in temples, cathedrals, and living rooms, maybe the heart of it lives in people more than institutions.

Leaving didn’t just shift our beliefs; it forced us to refall in love. We married young with a clear script—marry, serve, have children—and later discovered that real partnership means meeting each other again and again as new people. Around our ten-year mark, we had to decide whether to stay out of habit or choose each other with honesty. We chose the work: better conversations, fewer scorecards, and intimacy without fear. As parents, we now trade inherited answers for shared tools—curiosity, consent, accountability, and compassion—so our kids can build a self that fits from the inside.

If you’ve ever outgrown a belief, questioned a miracle, or wondered who you are without the script, this conversation is a warm hand on your shoulder. Join us as we make space for evolving truths, carry forward what’s beautiful, and let the rest go. If this resonates, subscribe, share with a friend, and leave a review—then tell us: what belief did you outgrow, and what did it make room for?

Support the show