Kinda Sorta Heretical (But Not Really) | Weird Hill to Die On EP#7

Is it heresy... or just uncomfortable theology? In this raw episode of Weird Hill to Die On, Adam Coleman, Phoenix Hayes, and Mary Jo Sharp dive into beliefs that get labeled as heretical—often unfairly. From Christmas trees and Calvinism to creation debates and God’s gender, they explore what makes a belief truly heretical versus just theologically adventurous. Expect deep dives into church history, spontaneous soap box moments, and just the right amount of sass. Whether you’re a heresy hunter or a recovering theology nerd, this episode is for you.

Key Topics Discussed

• What defines heresy vs. orthodox Christianity.
• Pagan origin claims about Christmas and Easter.
• The Calvinism vs. Arminianism vs. Molinism debate.
• Views on the un-evangelized and salvation boundaries.
• Young Earth vs. Old Earth creationism.
• Gender and the image of God (Is God non-binary?).
• The role of the early church, creeds, and councils in defining orthodoxy.
• Why “unity in essentials, liberty in non-essentials” matters.
• How theology gets weaponized in Christian culture.

Follow Weird Hill:

• Instagram: @weirdhillshow
• Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/weirdhillshow
• Website: https://weirdhillshow.com
• Spotify: https://tinyurl.com/weirdhillspotify