Get ready for another bonus episode, where Tayler and Colleen tell stories they pull from the tops of their noggins, and from the eerie depths of reddit. And in this episode, we have another skinwalker encounter story from Kilee! Grab a blanket, get cozy and get ready to embrace spooky season with us!

Have a story to tell? Email us at IGSTTYstories@gmail.com!

Back by popular demand — we got a whole lot spookier this week! We packed up our gear and headed to the famously haunted Jarrod’s Coffee in Mesa for a special bonus episode. Armed with our spirit box, we tried to make contact with whoever might still be lingering in the café.

From unexplained knocks to eerie voices coming through the static, this one had us looking over our shoulders the whole time. Grab your headphones, your coffee, and maybe some sage — because Jarrod’s doesn’t disappoint.

This week, Colleen and Tayler dive into not one, but two chilling legends of true crime and folklore.

Colleen takes us inside the twisted world of Ed Gein — the quiet Wisconsin farmer whose farmhouse of horrors shocked the world and inspired Psycho, The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, and Silence of the Lambs. From grave robbing to his infamous “woman suit,” Ed’s story proves sometimes the boogeyman is all too real.

Meanwhile, Tayler heads east to the Pine Barrens of New Jersey, where strange cries, hoofprints, and centuries of lore point to the winged cryptid locals call the Jersey Devil. Was it a cursed child, a colonial-era invention, or something darker still haunting the Garden State?

Two very different devils. One unforgettable episode.

On July 15, 1976, a summer school bus in Chowchilla, California, vanished with 26 children and their driver. Hours later, the bus was found abandoned — the kids and Ed Ray were gone without a trace. What followed was one of the largest child abductions in U.S. history, a nightmare that led to the victims being buried alive underground in a moving truck.

In this week’s solo episode, Colleen takes you inside the story: the terrifying hijacking, the frantic parents and FBI search above ground, the impossible fight for survival below, and the shocking truth about the men who orchestrated it all.

This is a case of resilience, community, and a bus ride that became a national nightmare.

This week on I’ve Got Something To Tell You, Tayler guides us through the eerie legends of Bachelor’s Grove, Chicago’s famously haunted cemetery where phantom cars, vanishing houses, and ghostly mourners still roam. Then Colleen pulls us across the Atlantic for the chilling true-crime tale of the Beast of Jersey, the masked predator who stalked the Channel Island for over a decade.

This week on I’ve Got Something to Tell You, we’re diving into both true crime and the paranormal. Colleen unpacks the haunting case of Tent Girl—a young woman discovered in a canvas bag off a Kentucky roadside in 1968, whose identity remained a mystery for decades. Then Tayler brings the spine-tingling story of Robert the Doll, one of the world’s most infamous haunted dolls, feared for his curses and chilling encounters in Key West.

If you love true crime podcasts, unsolved mysteries, and paranormal legends, “Dolls and Does” has it all—murder, mystery, and the kind of cursed energy that’ll have you questioning your camping trips and your childhood toys.

On this bonus episode, Colleen and Tayler talk near death experiences, ouija board stories + a personal one! And a true crime involving murder by mushrooms. Get cozy, and tune in!

Got a scary story? Email us at IGSTTYstories@gmail.com

This week, Colleen dives into the chilling and still-unsolved case of Cindy James, a nurse from British Columbia who reported years of stalking, threatening phone calls, and terrifying attacks before her mysterious death in 1989. Was Cindy truly the target of a relentless stalker—or was there something darker happening behind the scenes? We explore the evidence, theories, and lingering questions in one of Canada’s most haunting true crime cases.

Then, Tayler takes us out to sea with the eerie legends of ghost ships—from vessels found mysteriously abandoned to maritime tales of phantom crews and cursed waters. From the Mary Celeste to modern nautical mysteries, these stories prove that the ocean holds more secrets than we’ll ever know.

Join us for a mix of true crime, paranormal history, and WTF mysteries in this episode of I’ve Got Something to Tell You.