Identity – Mind-Bending Thriller or Forgettable Whodunit?

Prepare to have your mind twisted into knots, because this week on Underrated Favorites, we’re diving into the psychological thriller Identity.

This 2003 film, starring John Cusack, Ray Liotta, and Amanda Peet, has all the makings of a tense, classic whodunit: a group of strangers stranded at a motel during a violent storm, mysterious deaths, and a shocking twist. But does Identity stand out as a masterful thriller that keeps you guessing until the end, or does its convoluted plot twist collapse under its own weight?

We’ll take a look at how Identity blends psychological horror with classic murder mystery vibes, discussing whether its twist ending delivers a satisfying payoff or leaves too many unanswered questions. With a talented ensemble cast and a script that toys with the very notion of reality, does this movie deserve more recognition, or is it rightfully forgotten in the shuffle of early 2000s thrillers?

Plus, we’ll debate Identity’s influence on the genre—did it set a standard for the mind-bending mystery, or does it get lost among better-executed psychological thrillers? And as always, we’ll answer the ultimate question: Is Identity an underrated favorite that deserves a second look, or is it a forgettable flop?

Join us for a journey through the twists and turns of Identity, and find out whether this movie leaves you thrilled or just confused.

Subscribe to Underrated Favorites on your preferred podcast platform and follow us on social media to stay updated on what’s coming next. Spoiler alert: we’re tackling another horror classic next week and you won’t want to miss it!