Hunter Lewis | All Things Litigation In Family Law

Episode Summary

Melinda Eitzen talks with Hunter Lewis, a partner at Duffee + Eitzen, about the realities of litigation in family law cases. They explore what effective litigation really looks like—from client preparation and pleadings to evidence, trial strategy, and appellate considerations.

Hunter explains why honesty and full transparency from clients are essential to building an effective litigation strategy. Because courtrooms are an unnatural environment, thorough preparation and storytelling rooted in truth are critical. Melinda and Hunter also discuss the importance of properly drafted pleadings, handling cases involving family violence, navigating varying county evidence rules, and preserving the record for appeal. This episode provides a practical look at what goes into strong family law litigation from start to finish.

About the Guest

Hunter Lewis is a partner at Duffee + Eitzen and an experienced family law litigator.

Key Takeaways About Litigation in Family Law

● Client Transparency Matters: Clients help their attorneys most by sharing everything—not by trying to leave a good impression. Effective litigation relies on complete information to build strategy and tell the client’s story.

● Preparation Is Critical: Court is an unnatural environment. Thorough client preparation helps reduce uncertainty and improves courtroom performance.

● Honesty Wins: The most effective litigation strategies are rooted in truth. Taking ownership of the facts builds credibility, and judges respond to honesty.

● Pleadings Can Decide a Case: Poorly drafted pleadings can eliminate claims or entire cases. Pleadings must align with statutory requirements and be specific enough to preserve appellate rights.

● Evidence Rules Vary: Evidence rules can differ by county and court. Staying current with local rules is critical—failure to do so can result in excluded evidence.

● Motion for Directed Verdict: This motion argues the opposing party has failed to meet their burden of proof and is made after the other side rests but before presenting your case.

● Protecting the Record: Proper record-keeping is essential to support appeals or prevent them altogether. A clean record can make or break an appellate outcome.