Gilmore Girls S01E05 "Cinnamon's Wake" Reviewed

Carrie and Chemda dive into Cinnamon’s Wake, where Stars Hollow hits peak emotional weirdness after the tragic (and kind of hilarious?) loss of Babette and Morey’s beloved cat, Cinnamon. 😿

This episode sparks big reactions—disgust, horror, laughter—and a lot of “wait, what year is this?” commentary as our hosts wrestle with the pacing, tone, and drama of early-2000s storytelling.

Chemda reflects on the heart underneath the quirk, while Carrie’s still side-eyeing some choices. Lorelai’s romantic triangle heats up, and we ask: is it sweet, complicated… or just chaotic?