Episode 51 How to Turn your Inner Critic into Your Inner Coach

Do you ever feel like your own thoughts are holding you back?

In this episode Sarah explores how to turn your inner critic - the voice that fuels self-doubt and fear into your inner coach, the supportive inner voice that helps you thrive as a leader.

Sarah unpacks why this critical voice exists (spoiler: your brain’s trying to keep you safe!) and shares practical steps to quieten the self-criticism and strengthen your confidence.

You’ll learn how to recognise your inner critic, respond with compassion, and build a more empowering internal dialogue that helps you lead with clarity, courage, and calm.

Show Notes

[00:00:00] Welcome & Introduction

[00:01:00] Series Focus on Confidence

This episode kicks off a mini-series on confidence, exploring one of its biggest obstacles: the inner critic.

[00:02:00] The Power of the Inner Critic

How self-critical thoughts like “you’re not good enough” or “you’ll fail” affect confidence, performance, and relationships at work.

[00:03:00] Normalising the Inner Critic

Everyone has an inner critic, even confident leaders. The key difference is how we manage it.

[00:04:00] Why We Have an Inner Critic

A neuroscience perspective: the limbic brain is wired to keep us safe by scanning for risk—especially emotional risk and uses self-criticism to stop us taking action.

[00:06:00] Case Study: Toni’s Story

Sarah shares Toni’s experience, a senior leader driven by perfectionism and self-doubt, and how learning to coach herself helped prevent burnout.

[00:07:30] Step 1: Notice the Voice

Start by observing your inner critic. What does it say? When does it appear? Writing these thoughts down helps create awareness and perspective.

[00:09:00] Step 2: Recognise You Have a Choice

You can choose how you speak to yourself. Developing self-compassion is a superpower - talk to yourself as you would a close friend.

[00:10:00] Understanding the Brain’s Intention

Your critic’s goal is protection, not punishment. Acknowledge it's fear instead of fighting it.

[00:11:00] Step 3: Change the Dialogue

Learn to reframe negative thoughts into constructive self-talk. Example: turning “I can’t do that” into “How can I do that?”

[00:12:00] Real-Life Example: Reframing Burnout Fear

A client learns to thank her inner critic for trying to protect her, while reassuring it that she’s now equipped with better boundaries and resilience.

[00:13:00] Step 4: Strengthen Your Inner Coach

Amplify your supportive inner voice by gathering evidence of your strengths, achievements, and positive feedback.

[00:15:00] Tools to Boost Your Inner Coach

• Keep an achievement journal
• Practice positive self-talk and affirmations
• Surround yourself with uplifting content - books, podcasts, music, and meditation

[00:16:00] Balancing Compassion & Confidence

You don’t need to silence your inner critic, just let it relax while your inner coach takes the lead.

[00:17:00] Recap & Reflection

Sarah summarises the four steps:

1. Notice your inner critic
2. Choose compassion
3. Reframe your self-talk
4. Strengthen your inner coach

[00:18:00] Closing Message

If you’d like personalised support in developing your inner coach, reach out via careertreecoaching.co.uk.

Remember:...