Episode 133 - Jefferson's Presidential 18 year

Send us Fan Mail

A bourbon can be rare, expensive, and still disappoint. That’s why we finally went for it and put Jefferson’s Presidential Select 18 Year in the glass, the kind of “unicorn bourbon” people whisper about at whiskey bars and chase at auctions. This pour is tied to Stitzel-Weller barrels, distilled in 1991, bottled at 94 proof, and loaded with the kind of backstory that makes collectors argue for hours about what’s real value and what’s just hype.

We walk through the Stitzel-Weller legacy and the Van Winkle family timeline so the label actually means something: how wheated bourbon became iconic, what changed when the distillery closed in the early ’90s, and how various brands ended up with those aging stocks. From there, we connect the dots on Jefferson’s origins as a non-distiller producer and why buying fully aged barrels in the late ’90s turned into a once-in-a-generation move. If you care about bourbon history, sourced whiskey, dusty whiskey, or the Pappy Van Winkle ecosystem, this is the context that makes the sip hit harder.

Then we taste it for real. We talk nose, palate, mouthfeel, and finish with the details that matter: sweet caramel, toffee-like sugar, raisin and wine notes, dusty mature oak, gentle wheat character, and a surprising pop of spice for a wheater. We also get honest about the “sharing problem” with bottles like this, because some whiskeys aren’t party pours, they’re life-moment pours.

If you’re into rare bourbon reviews, Jefferson’s Presidential Select, Stitzel-Weller lore, or just love a deep tasting breakdown, hit play. Subscribe, share this with a bourbon friend, and leave a review, then tell us: would you open a bottle like this or keep it sealed?