Ep 131 - What Makes a True Oktoberfest Beer?

Send us a text

The line between tradition and interpretation blurs when American breweries tackle the iconic Oktoberfest beer style. After recently sampling authentic German Märzens and Festbiers, we now turn our attention to seven American interpretations to see how they measure up to the originals.

What we discover is both surprising and revealing. While German Oktoberfest beers demonstrate remarkable consistency in their rich, malty profiles, American versions showcase wildly varying approaches—most falling short of capturing the essence that makes the German originals so special. The appearance might be there, with appropriate amber-to-copper hues, but the flavor profiles tell a different story.

Our journey begins with disappointment as the first three American offerings (Lakefront, Schell's, and Raised Grain) present appealing aromas but deliver minimal flavor, scoring in the low 2.0 range. The middle entries introduce more character but veer off in unexpected directions, with Sierra Nevada's collaboration with German brewery Störtebeker leaving a peculiar dryness that departs from tradition.

Only when we reach the final two entries—Lake Louie and New Glarus Staghorn—do we find American interpretations that begin to approach the authentic Oktoberfest experience. The Staghorn, with its smooth finish and balanced malt profile, earns our highest score at 2.7/5, yet even this falls significantly short of the German originals that scored up to 3.6/5.

What becomes clear through our tasting is that brewing an authentic Oktoberfest isn't simply about matching color and alcohol content—it requires a deep understanding of the malt balance and brewing techniques that German brewers have perfected over centuries. While none of the American versions are bad beers per se, they often miss the mark on what makes an Oktoberfest truly special.

Whether you're a seasoned Oktoberfest enthusiast or new to the style, this episode offers valuable guidance on navigating American interpretations. If you can't find German imports, New Glarus Staghorn and Lake Louie represent your best options for experiencing something close to the real thing. Listen in as we analyze each beer's strengths and shortcomings, and gain a deeper appreciation for this classic autumn style.

Thank you for listening to The Northwoods Beer Guy Podcast. If you have a question, comment or would like us to review your beer, please feel free to contact us at [e-mail].

You can also find us on Facebook, YouTube, X (Twitter), Instagram and Tik Tok.

If you are on Untappd, look up NorthwoodsBeerGuy and send a friend request.

Subscribe to our podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Pandora, YouTube Music, or wherever you listen to podcasts, or you can click on our RSS feed as well.