Ep. 112 – From CRO to CEO: What Boards Really Look for in Sales Leaders with Jason Baumgarten - Part 1

In this episode of Selling the Cloud, Mark Petruzzi and KK Anderson are joined by Jason Baumgarten, Global Head of the CEO and Board Practice at Spencer Stuart, to unpack what truly separates sales leaders who advance into CEO and board roles from those who remain stuck at the functional level.Drawing from more than 250 CEO and board transitions, Jason shares a rare behind-the-scenes perspective on how boards evaluate CROs, why ambition alone is not enough, and what sales leaders must change as they move from execution to enterprise leadership. The conversation explores founder-led transitions, boardroom presence, customer lifecycle thinking, and why sales excellence alone does not guarantee executive readiness.This episode is essential listening for CROs, founders, and revenue leaders who want to move beyond quota and operate at the highest levels of leadership.What You’ll Learn:From CRO to CEO: The mindset shifts sales leaders must make to be considered for top executive and board rolesBoardroom Credibility: How sales leaders can show up as strategic business operators, not just revenue ownersFounder Transitions: When founder-led selling breaks and what must change to scale the organizationSystems Thinking: Why understanding the full revenue and customer lifecycle matters more than pipeline aloneExecutive Readiness Signals: What boards look for when evaluating senior sales leadersHiring at the Right Time: Common board mistakes when transitioning away from founder-led salesKey Topics:Evolving from sales operator to strategic executive CRO presence and influence in the boardroomFounder-led sales versus scalable go-to-market systemsRetention, lifecycle metrics, and long-term growth signalsBoard governance and leadership transitionsWhy sales is not always the answerGuest Spotlight: Jason BaumgartenJason Baumgarten is the Global Head of the CEO and Board Practice at Spencer Stuart, where he leads executive search and board advisory engagements for companies ranging from early-stage ventures to multi-billion-dollar enterprises. He has advised on more than 250 CEO and board transitions, with deep expertise in founder-led technology companies, succession planning, and board effectiveness.Before joining Spencer Stuart, Jason was an Associate Principal at McKinsey and a Program Manager at Microsoft. He holds an MBA from Stanford Graduate School of Business, serves as Chairman of the Board for IslandWood, and is a frequent contributor to Harvard Business Review, including his article How CEOs Build Confidence in Their Leadership.Resources & Mentions:• Spencer Stuart• Harvard Business Review: How CEOs Build Confidence in Their Leadership• Mark Roberge: The Science of Scaling🎧 Listen now and follow Selling the Cloud for conversations with leaders shaping the future of go-to-market, executive leadership, and board-level decision making.Mark Petruzzi (00:37)Welcome to today's episode of Selling the Cloud Podcast. I'm thrilled to welcome Jason Baumgarten, Global Head of the CEO and Board Practice at Spencer Stewart. Jason leads Executive Search and Board Advisory for one of the world's premier leadership consulting firms. He's completed over 250 CEO and Board Transitions.across companies ranging from early stage ventures to multi-billion dollar enterprises. His expertise spans CEO succession planning, board effectiveness, and leadership transitions, particularly for founder led technology companies. Before Spencer Stewart, Jason was an associate principal at McKinsey and a program manager at Microsoft.He holds an MBA from Stanford's Graduate School of Business and serves as chairman of the board for Island Wood. His thought leadership appears regularly in the Harvard Business Review, including a recent article, How CEOs Build Confidence in Their Leadership. What makes Jason's perspective uniquely valuable is his vantage point. He's interviewed thousands of sales leaders and observes whatseparates those who successfully transitioned to CEO and board roles from those who just can't get there. Today we'll explore four critical themes. The sales leaders evolution from operator to strategic executive. Founder transitions building a leadership capacity beyond the go-to-market motion. Board governance for sales leaders. Why thinking like an investor makes you better at your job.and landing your next role, what really matters at the senior executive level. So I guess a couple of things there. You really don't work hard enough or really haven't accomplished most in your life Mano man, Jason, what an amazing career you've had already.And I'm sure you're not going to be slowing down anytime soon. So thank you. Thank you for joining us and joining us here on Selling the Cloud podcast.Jason Baumgarten (02:40)Well, thanks for having me. And I felt a little tired listening to it, but it was all fun in the moment and delighted to try and share some learnings from the many, many, interviews and board discussions and CEO ...