E602 - One Perfect Episode vs 52 Good Ones - What Wins for Podcasters

Episode 602 - One Perfect Episode vs 52 Good Ones - What Wins for Podcasters

In this episode of the How to Podcast series, host Dave dives into the timeless debate of quality versus quantity in podcasting, sparked by discussions in his podcasting community. Drawing from his ambitious 2026 plan to release 365 daily episodes across multiple shows—while juggling a full-time job, coaching, editing, and more—he shares why he's leaning into high-volume creation without sacrificing value. Episodes are thoughtfully batch-recorded ahead of time, ensuring consistency and preventing burnout, as Dave explains how regular output turns his show into a listener habit rather than a seasonal event that risks audience drift.

Dave uses his 45-year music background to illustrate the point: musicians don't perfect one song endlessly; they produce volumes of work, with hits emerging from the sheer act of repetition, much like podcasters hone skills through deliberate practice. He references the 10,000-hour principle, noting that weekly creators get 52 chances yearly to refine delivery, topics, and engagement, compared to just 12 for monthly ones. More episodes mean richer analytics data—from Instagram flops to YouTube insights—fueling faster growth and algorithm favor. Yet he acknowledges quality's merits for niche experts with limited time, warning against perfectionism that delays launches or filler content that overwhelms.

Balancing both, Dave advocates a hybrid: sustainable cadences like weekly 20-30 minute episodes, polished via editing and listener feedback, perhaps with short host reflections post-interview. Track metrics like downloads and time spent listening to iterate. In a bonus for dedicated listeners, he reveals his interview secret—treating guests like band soloists, stepping back to let them shine, informed by live performance dynamics.

Key Takeaway: Aim for consistent quantity to accelerate mastery and audience habits, but layer in quality through feedback and editing—do what fits your life, as even one great episode done regularly beats sporadic perfection

___

Helping Podcasters Everyday!

https://howtopodcast.ca/

We would love to hear from you - here is our listener survey!

https://forms.gle/GbrFv9DGszV8N4PW6