Do You Need Stars To Get A D1 Football Scholarship? (Are Rankings a SCAM?)

In this episode of The Football Scholarship Podcast, Richie Contartesi and cohost Brian Overton, a recruiting expert with 15 years of Division 1 experience, break down the truth about star rankings—and whether they actually matter when it comes to earning a scholarship.

They expose the rise of fake “5-star” athletes, how most rankings are misunderstood or misused, and why chasing stars could hurt your son’s chances more than help. You’ll also learn how real offers happen, what college coaches actually look for, and how athletes are winning scholarships without rankings, camps, or hype.

If you’ve ever wondered whether your son needs to be ranked or attend exposure events, this episode will give you the honest answers—and a clear path forward.