The Girls are joined by Emma Oliver in discussing Samuel Little, America’s most prolific serial killer. They talk about smashable Texas Rangers, Veronica’s love of men with talent, and why it’s important to use profiles correctly. Kristen is back with another Peer Review that asks ‘can psychopaths feel love?,’ as well as the most important question: How many wind chimes is too many? 

This episode can be tied to Criminal Minds season 2, episode 13: No Way Out.

The Girls are not joined by Jay Washington and are left to discuss Wayne Williams and the Atlanta Child Murders alone. There are a lot of twists and turns and coverups and backroom dealings with this reopened and ongoing investigation. The South after the Civil Rights Movement, the Klan, and 28 murdered and missing young people. This is one of the beginning cases for profiling and proves how important it is not to use a profile incorrectly. Discover why on this week’s episode!
This episode can be tied to Criminal minds season 2, episode 12: Profiler, Profiled.

The Girls are joined by Megan Oesterreich in discussing Danilo Restivo, Italian murderer and hair fanatic. They also pose questions like: ‘are there any good Ronald’s?’, ‘what music do you want to be murdered to?’, and ‘should this be an Anton Yelchin or Crispin Glover appreciation podcast?’ Find out about Stacy’s birthday twin and some new CG merch ideas on this week’s all new episode!

This episode can be tied to Criminal Minds season 2, episode 11: Sex, Birth, Death.

The Girls are joined by Rocky Roberts in discussing Shoko Asahara and the doomsday cult of Aum Shinrikyo. They talk about Rocky’s disdain for Criminal Minds while the puppies of the show, Bartok and Rogue, make their presences known. Are churches cults, would you join Veronica’s cult, and what happens when yoga turns deadly? Find out on this week’s episode!

This episode can be tied to Criminal Minds season 2, episode 10: Lessons Learned.

The Girls are joined by Kim Lupe in discussing the Baton Rouge Serial Killers, Derrick Todd Lee and Sean Vincent Gillis. Amanda and Kristen are back with Our Buddy Bundy and Peer Review segments, respectfully; and there is a lot of talk about necrophilia — how fun! They talk all things Shemar Moore, Emily Prentiss (finally!), and how to kidnap Kim.

This episode can be tied to Criminal Minds season 2, episode 9: The Last Word.

The Girls are joined by Aviv Rubinstien in discussing The Unabomber, Ted Kaczynski. It’s a deep episode where they talk about MK-Ultra, linguistic forensics, political ideologies, horseshoe theory, and how America creates its own monsters. But don’t worry, Shemar Moore is still objectified! What does Osama bin Laden, Ramzi Yousef, Tim McVeigh, and the movie Speed have to do with Ted Kaczynski? And where does the Inbetweeners and the Sausage King of Chicago fit into the story? Find out on this week’s episode!

This episode can be tied to Criminal Minds season 2, episode 8: Empty Planet.

The Girls are joined by Anastasia Washington in discussing the Ariel Castro kidnappings of Amanda Berry, Michelle Knight and Gina DeJesus. It’s Stacy’s turn to struggle with pronunciations and an itch she just has to scratch. It’s not a great time for fast food franchises, and they answer the burning questions like: did the 80s have color photography. They’re still looking for that corporate sponsor on this week’s episode! This week’s episode can be tied to Criminal Minds season 2, episode 7: North Mammon.

The Girls are joined by Joseph Schles to talk about Mary Bell, and little kid killers. They discuss Elle’s last episode (thank god!) and have the easiest Gimme Moore so far! Stacy learns some British slang while we discover iPhone updates in real time. Is Boston Market still around? And what does Bear World Magazine have to do with this? Find out in this week’s all new episode!

This week’s episode can be tied to Criminal Minds season 2, episode 6: The Boogeyman.