Cindy Song was a 21-year-old Penn State student who vanished without a trace after a Halloween party in 2001. She was dropped off at her apartment around 4 a.m. and was never seen again. Her purse, keys, and ID were missing, but her phone and backpack were left behind. Despite widespread media attention, numerous theories, and possible connections to known criminals, her case remains unsolved 24 years later.

On April 15th, 2012, 15-year-old Chelsea Johnson was found brutally stabbed to death in a shallow creek near the apartment she shared with her mother in Fairfield, Ohio. The crime scene, compromised by water and exposure, offered little in the way of physical evidence. With mounting public pressure and no clear suspect, investigators quickly arrested a local man, but the arrest lacked solid evidence, and charges were later dropped. Over a decade has passed, and the case remains unsolved. Chelsea’s family is still left with more questions than answers. In this episode, we revisit the case that’s haunted a community for over ten years, in search of the truth behind Chelsea Johnson’s murder.

In June 2021, 47-year-old James Valdez left his home after a heated argument with his wife. Days later, his vehicle was found abandoned near a secluded swimming hole in Sugar Grove, Arkansas—with the engine dismantled, his personal belongings missing, and a chilling message scrawled on the back window.

James hasn’t been seen since.

In this episode, we dive into the timeline, conflicting witness accounts, strange discoveries, and the many unanswered questions surrounding his case.