Today we look at the compassionate conservatism and its relevance in today's political climate with historian John Fea. We examine the origins of this movement, rooted in social justice and faith-based initiatives, and its initial implementation during the George W. Bush administration, particularly through programs like PEPFAR. John highlights how the philosophy has deteriorated under the Trump administration, which marked a shift towards isolationism and away from collective responsibility. We explore the evangelical community's surprising loyalty to Trump, despite contradictions with compassionate conservatism, and reflect on the need for a revitalization of these principles through education and dialogue.

Articles by John Fea:

The Big Beautiful Bill is the 'final burial of compassionate conservatism'

The Big Beautiful Bill will pass the House as Christians turn a blind eye.

Donate to Church and Main

Join the Church and Main Email List

churchandmain@substack.com

Facebook | Instagram | Threads | Twitter | Website | YouTube

Todd Stavrakos discusses the mission of Pathways for Peace, focusing on fostering dialogue between the Jewish and mainline Christian communities regarding the Israel-Palestine conflict. He highlights the current humanitarian crisis in Gaza and the complexities of the situation, including the roles of Hamas and the Israeli government. The discussion also touches on the historical context of the conflict, the influence of leadership dynamics, media narratives, and the church's response to the ongoing issues. Stavrakos emphasizes the need for a balanced perspective and the importance of supporting peacebuilding efforts.

Pathways for Middle East Peace

Donate to Church and Main

Join the Church and Main Email List

churchandmain@substack.com

Facebook | Instagram | Threads | Twitter | Website | YouTube

I chat with Jason Micheli, a United Methodist pastor, on the pitfalls of pathos in politics, emphasizing its potential to overshadow core Christian tenets. Drawing on Jason's article "Deprive Them of Their Pathos," we reflect on Karl Barth’s theological insights, arguing against conflating faith with political ideologies. Our conversation addresses the challenges of preaching in a politically charged climate and the need for churches to avoid becoming echo chambers. We highlight the importance of humility, grace, and intersectional engagement within the church, ultimately reinforcing our commitment to the transformative mission of the gospel amidst societal divisions.

Deprive Them Of Their Pathos by Jason Micheli

Tamed Cynic Blog

Crackers and Grape Juice Podcast

Donate to Church and Main

Join the Church and Main Email List

churchandmain@substack.com

Facebook | Instagram | Threads | Twitter | Website | YouTube