Church Consultants React to Social Media Christmas Clips

In this special Christmas episode of the Church Revitalization Podcast, Scott Ball and A.J. Mathieu react in real time to a series of viral Christmas-themed church and Christian videos circulating online. From funny and lighthearted moments to intense theological takes and over-the-top productions, this episode explores how Christians communicate faith during the Christmas season—and how those messages are received by both believers and the watching world.

Scott Ball is joined by co-host and fellow church consultant A.J. Mathieu as they offer candid, unscripted reactions rooted in decades of ministry experience. Together, they discuss pastoral wisdom, cultural engagement, outreach effectiveness, and where well-intended Christmas expressions may help—or hurt—the church's witness.

Chapters

[00:00] Introduction

[02:15] Pastors, humor, and calling out fruitcake from the pulpit

[04:41] "God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen" and why punctuation matters in theology

[07:45] Is Christmas pagan? Responding to extreme anti-Christmas arguments

[12:44] Cross-shaped Christmas trees and symbolic overcorrections

[18:08] "Christmas at the Movies" sermon series—helpful or overdone?

[24:20] Mega-church Christmas productions, ticket prices, and public perception

[34:12] A deeper look at A Christmas Carol and the dangers of moral rigidity

Links & Resources

• Healthy Churches Toolkit - https://healthychurchestoolkit.com
• The Malphurs Group - https://malphursgroup.com
• Facebook - https://facebook.com/malphursgroup
• Instagram - https://instagram.com/malphursgroup
• YouTube - https://youtube.com/themalphursgroup
• X (Twitter) - https://x.com/malphursgroup