Can ChatGPT Be Your Therapist? The Hidden Risks of AI in Mental Health

Awake at the Wheel | Ep 97

In this episode of Awake at the Wheel, we dive into the messy, fascinating question: Can AI ever really replace a human therapist? Using tools like ChatGPT as a jumping-off point, we unpack where AI can be helpful—and where it becomes downright dangerous. We explore why real healing depends on human connection, empathy, and a genuine therapeutic relationship that no algorithm can truly mimic. We also look at the risks of vulnerable people turning to chatbots for support, the ethical and clinical pitfalls of treating AI like a therapist, and why accessible, high-quality mental health care is more crucial now than ever.

Takeaways

-ChatGPT isn't a viable replacement for real-life therapists.
-Humans are emotional and selective in interactions with chatbots.
-Parents should monitor children's online engagement with chatbots.
-AI can provide psychoeducational support but not replace therapy.
-Therapeutic rapport is crucial for effective therapy.
-AI lacks the ability to pick up on non-verbal cues.
-Chatbots can reinforce maladaptive beliefs if not used cautiously.
-AI should be an adjunct, not a replacement, for therapy.
-Proper mental health care access is essential to prevent reliance on AI.
-Human therapists provide empathy and insight that AI cannot.

Chapters

00:00:53 Introduction to AI in Therapy
00:01:19 The Role of AI in Mental Health
00:01:44 Case Study: Risks of AI in Therapy
00:03:33 Limitations of Chatbots
00:05:13 The Importance of Human Connection
00:10:02 AI as an Adjunct, Not Replacement
00:15:00 Future of AI in Therapy

We want your questions! Future episodes will feature a new segment, Rounds Table, where Malini and Dr Amitay will answer your questions, discuss your comments, and explore your ideas. Send your questions to [e-mail], tweet us @awakepod, send us a message at facebook.com/awakepod, or leave a comment on this video!

Email
Insta
Youtube
Facebook
Twitter