Brand Imitation: Lessons, Risks, and the Way Forward

Not long ago, I was on a long drive. My phone battery was running dangerously low, and I had forgotten my car charger. The previous night, I hadn’t charged the phone fully either, so I was running out of power fast. Along the way, I spotted a shop that looked promising, a bright, well-arranged phone accessories store. From outside, you could see neat displays of chargers, cables, headphones, and other gadgets. I pulled over, walked in, and asked for a charger. The shopkeeper confidently presented a range of options. He assured me that all were “good quality,” and encouraged me to test one. As I looked around the shop more carefully, something caught my eye. Almost everything in that store was an imitation. Ninety-nine percent of the products carried names that looked familiar but were not quite right. A “NOKRI” instead of Nokia. “Samsong” instead of Samsung. A tiny tweak in spelling, logo, or packaging, but the clear intention was to imitate trusted brands. The young man selling them believed in what he was offering. He insisted these were reliable and affordable alternatives. But to me, the reality was different. These were products built on deception, meant to confuse customers who weren’t paying close attention. That visit left me reflecting. Why do some businesses rely so heavily on imitation? What makes a brand so attractive that others feel the need to copy it? And more importantly, how can original brands guard against this without losing focus on their core mission? Every strong brand, at some point, faces imitation. It’s almost inevitable. The better your product, the more likely someone, somewhere, will try to replicate or counterfeit it. Books get pirated. Music gets duplicated. Software gets hacked. Shoes, phones, detergents, clothing, you name them. Once people see that a product is valuable, they will attempt to ride on its name. But imitation carries two sides: it can be a compliment, and at the same time, a threat. I would like to explore both. I’ll share real-life stories, lessons from the market, and practical ways brands can protect themselves while still growing boldly and authentically. Why Great Brands Get Imitated One of the first truths to settle in your mind as a brand builder is this: imitation is often the tax you pay for excellence. People rarely copy what isn’t working. If your product or service is being imitated, it usually means you are doing something right. Think about it, nobody bothers pirating a book that nobody is reading. No one wastes energy duplicating software that has no users. Nobody forges a brand that consumers don’t respect. Imitation is often the strongest signal that your brand has crossed a certain threshold of relevance. When I stood in that phone accessories shop, staring at the “NOKRI” cables and “Samsong” chargers, it struck me: these big names had become so dominant that their identity was a magnet. Even a poor imitation of their names carried some weight in the marketplace. To the casual customer, seeing a name that looked familiar was enough to assume quality. That is the hidden advantage strong brands enjoy—the mere recognition of their names influences purchase decisions. The same is true in publishing. For years, I have seen authors complain about piracy. But think about it: a pirated book is hardly ever a poorly selling one. It’s the bestsellers that get copied. If a book has no impact, no one takes the trouble to scan, print, or circulate it illegally. So, strangely, piracy is proof of value—though it’s still a threat that must be dealt with wisely. We see this across industries: The principle is simple: only the visible, valuable, and desirable get imitated. Now, should brands take pride in being imitated? In a sense, yes, it’s a sign that your work carries weight. But that’s only one side of the coin. The other side is dangerous, because imitation can also dilute trust, confuse customers, and undercut genuine innovation. And that’s where the challenge lies.