Brand Controversy & Social Media: Pause, Post, or Pivot?

What should brands do when controversy hits — or worse, when they create it?

In this episode of The Marketing Blender Show, Sa Maria Boyd and Kylie Scarborough break down how major brands handled (and sometimes mishandled) high-visibility social media moments — from Duolingo’s AI-first backlash to American Eagle’s campaign controversy, Cracker Barrel’s rebrand reversal, and Southwest Airlines’ policy changes.

When public sentiment is heightened, culture is shifting, and emotions are running high, marketers don’t have the luxury of “just posting.” Every message is amplified. Every silence is interpreted. And every decision has consequences.

We explore:

-Whether all press is really good press

-When brands should pause content during cultural or global tension

-The role of social media managers in crisis communication

-Why humor sometimes works — and sometimes falls flat

-How nostalgia, identity, and brand equity impact backlash

-When it’s smart to stand your ground… and when to pivot

This conversation is especially relevant for B2B marketers who often believe controversy is a “B2C problem.” It’s not. Social media is now the front line of brand reputation for every industry.

If you're releasing something that could even be perceived as controversial, double-check it. You may overthink it. You may delay it. You may even lose money adjusting the plan.

But the bigger question remains:

Is the short-term attention worth the long-term brand damage?

Social media managers carry more strategic weight than many organizations realize. They’re not just posting content — they have a pulse on culture. And in moments of crisis, that insight matters.