This week on Bite Me, Sierra dives into the heartbreaking and mysterious disappearance of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie from Tucson, Arizona.

Nancy, the mother of Today Show anchor Savannah Guthrie, vanished from her Catalina Foothills home after being dropped off by family on January 31, 2026. Hours later, her doorbell camera disconnected, motion was detected, and her pacemaker app went offline. By Sunday morning, her family found blood on her porch and no sign of her.

With signs of foul play, possible ransom notes, FBI involvement, and no suspects publicly named, this case has shaken the Tucson community and captured national attention.

In this episode, we break down: • The final hours before Nancy disappeared • The chilling overnight timeline • Evidence found at the home • The ransom note chaos • The family’s emotional plea • Where the investigation stands now

If you have information, contact the Pima County Sheriff’s Department at 520-351-4900 or call 911.

This week on Bite Me, the true crime news cycle brought chaos in bulk.

We’re breaking down four stories that spiraled across courtrooms, classrooms, and jail cells.

Major twist in the killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson. A federal judge has ruled that Luigi Mangione will not face the death penalty if convicted, dismissing firearms charges tied to capital punishment while leaving life-in-prison charges firmly on the table. Federal prosecutors stumble, state prosecutors speed up, and a backpack full of alleged evidence stays in play.

A shocking incident out of Billings, Montana. An 18-year-old student allegedly stabbed a math teacher after school before turning the knife on herself. The case is still developing, and rumors, screenshots, and unanswered questions are spreading faster than confirmed facts.

Bizarre jailbreak fantasy that belongs in a late-night sketch. A Minnesota man allegedly impersonated an FBI agent in an attempt to free Mangione from a Brooklyn jail, armed with a barbecue fork and a pizza cutter. He is now being held in the same facility as the man he allegedly tried to save.

And finally, a case that refuses to stay quiet. We check in on another unfolding true crime headline making waves this week, where timelines don’t line up, official statements feel thin, and the internet is already several conspiracy theories ahead.

Four stories. Zero closure. All alleged. All ongoing. All very much still unraveling.

Press play. Take a bite. 🖤🦷

Sierra’s brand-new weekly true crime snack, is making its debut right here. Short, sharp, and just a little feral, Bite Me serves up bite-sized updates. This week we talk about updates in the Buzzard case, tell you whats happing in the case of Mckee and share the verdict in the Uvalde trial and chat about Haros appearance in court this week.

A grief book after a suspicious death. A murder investigation tied to a staged scene. And a woman missing for decades suddenly found alive.

This week’s headlines prove sometimes the story told… isn’t the truth investigators uncover.

This week on Bite Me, Sierra breaks down the true crime stories everyone is talking about and the details raising serious questions.

A Utah children’s book author Kouri Richins is accused of poisoning her husband before publishing a book about grief. Investigators say a supposed home invasion may have been staged after a worship leader Caleb Flynn is charged with his wife’s murder. Major developments emerge in the death of teenager Anna Kepner aboard a cruise ship, and a missing mother discovered alive after 24 years is suddenly taken into custody.

Plus, a continuing update on the search for Nancy Guthrie as her family offers a $1 million reward for information.

Each week, Bite Me covers what’s trending, what’s alleged, and what’s raising eyebrows in true crime, all in one bite-sized serving.

Take everything with context, skepticism, and care.

That’s your bite, besties. Stay sharp.

This week on Bite Me, we’re serving up a three-course true crime meal:

• Nancy Guthrie — Surveillance footage shows a masked man at her front door. DNA has given investigators the first solid lead in this ongoing mystery.
• The Banfield Case — A supposed home invasion unravels into a lethal plot involving a fake FetLife profile, an au pair, and a husband now convicted of murdering his wife.
• Tawnia McGeehan — A tragedy in Las Vegas as a mother kills her daughter at a cheerleading tournament before taking her own life. Facts are limited, but the heartbreak is real.

Join me, Sierra, as we break down the latest updates, court developments, and key forensic details — all delivered with a little side eye.

Follow Bite Me wherever you get your podcasts for your weekly serving of true crime updates.

Socials:

• Follow Unsolved Couple for bonus content and deeper dives
• Check our umbrella podcast and main socials for updates on ongoing cases