The tides have turned in New York baseball, and not in the Yankees’ favor. In Episode 21, the Bronx Bombers find themselves down 2-0 in the ALDS to the Toronto Blue Jays after a grueling Wild Card win over the Red Sox that briefly reignited hope in the Bronx. Ed breaks down what’s gone wrong so far — from missed opportunities to shaky bullpen moments — while Alec, whose Mets are long out of the picture, takes every chance to twist the knife and root for Toronto to finish the job.

It’s rivalry energy at its peak, with Alec’s petty glee meeting Ed’s frustrated optimism as we dissect what’s left for the Yankees to fight for — and what it would mean for New York if the city’s October dreams end this early. From dugout decisions to dug-in banter, Episode 21 captures the essence of every Mets fan’s favorite pastime: watching the Yankees sweat.

The regular season is over, and New York baseball fans are feeling every emotion possible. In Episode 20, we dive into the Mets’ official elimination from playoff contention — a crushing finish that left Alec furious and heartbroken after holding out hope until the very end. What was supposed to be a season of promise ends in disappointment, and we break down how it all fell apart.

Meanwhile, across town, the Yankees are preparing for a high-stakes Wild Card showdown against their oldest rival, the Boston Red Sox. The Bronx Bombers have momentum and swagger, but the intensity of October baseball is about to be tested in one of the sport’s fiercest matchups.

From Alec’s raw reaction to the Mets’ collapse to Ed’s cautious confidence about the Yankees’ chances, we capture the split emotions of New York fans as one chapter slams shut and another one begins.

The New York baseball rollercoaster just took a sharp turn. In Episode 19, we dive into the Mets’ brutal collapse, how they’ve fallen out of a playoff spot, and what went wrong in a season that once looked promising. Meanwhile, the Yankees are staying hot and sharpening their edge as October baseball draws near, giving fans plenty of reason to believe.

We also welcome our first-ever guest: Alec’s buddy Mikey, a diehard but pessimistic Mets fan, who brings a raw, unfiltered take on what it feels like to watch this team unravel. From bullpen meltdowns to missed opportunities, we break down the heartbreak in Queens, the momentum in the Bronx, and what it all means for New York baseball fans heading into the final push.

The final stretch of the season is here, and New York baseball is telling two very different stories. In Episode 18, we break down the Mets’ continued inconsistency, their struggles to put wins together, and why the division race is slipping away. Meanwhile, the Yankees are scrapping to stay alive in the AL East battle, showing just enough fight to keep their hopes alive.
We dig into the biggest turning points of the past two weeks, who’s trending up and down, and what both clubs need to lock in before October arrives. Plus, as always, some spirited back-and-forth on which New York team fans should feel better about heading into the home stretch.

After a long hiatus, we’re back behind the mic and catching up on everything we missed in New York baseball. Episode 17 dives into the aftermath of the trade deadline, breaking down where the Mets and Yankees stand, what’s missing, and what absolutely needs to improve in the final sprint of the season.

We look at roster gaps, the players who need to step up, and which teams are truly built for the stretch run. Plus, we take our first-ever caller—a Padres fan—who calls out the Mets and sparks some lively banter about where New York baseball really stands.

After a red-hot stretch, both the Mets and Yankees have slammed into a brutal cold spell—and Episode 16 dives straight into the wreckage. We break down the ugly stretch where New York baseball went from surging to sputtering.

From lifeless bats and shaky bullpens to key injuries and roster shakeups, we dissect what went wrong, who's to blame, and whether this is just a midseason stumble—or something bigger.

Plus, we spotlight the biggest under-performers, unexpected call-ups, and whether fans should panic or preach patience.

The heat is on in the city—and so are both squads. In Episode 15, Alec and Ed break down a red-hot stretch of New York baseball as the Yankees and Mets keep stacking wins. We open with a full recap of the last week and a half: who's surging, what's fueling the streaks, and whether this level of play feels built to last.

Then it's time for a Heat Check—highlighting the biggest hitters, dominant arms, and surprise standouts from both sides of town. We wrap with the return of the Quippy Awards: from the best at-bat to the coldest bat, the wildest stat to the wildest crowd moment—this segment has it all.

Two teams. One city. All gas, no breaks.

The Subway Series is in the rearview—and now both New York teams are surging. The Mets are catching fire, the Yankees look unstoppable, and Episode 14 breaks down who’s stepping up and what’s actually sustainable. From Alonso’s resurgence to Judge’s MVP rampage, we cover the biggest trends. Plus, we hand out our first-ever NY Baseball Awards: bold, unfiltered, and totally chaotic.