Beyond the First Gift: How Smart Nonprofits Keep Donors Giving

Send a text

What happens after the first donation may matter even more than the donation itself! Lauren Laski, Manager of Customer Success at Bloomerang, talks about how nonprofit organizations can build stronger donor relationships, improve retention, and create more reliable revenue over time.

Lauren brings both fundraising and technology experience to the conversation, and she offers a clear reminder that the first donation should never be treated as the finish line. Instead, it should be seen as the start of a longer relationship. Lauren explains the power of prompt gratitude. She shares that when a first-time donor is thanked within 48 hours, they are “four times more likely to make a second gift.” That one practice alone can completely change how a nonprofit approaches stewardship.

The conversation, with host Julia Patrick, also moves into recurring giving, which Lauren describes as one of the strongest tools for long-term donor retention and revenue stability. With recurring donors retaining at a much higher rate, nonprofits can reduce the feast-or-famine cycle that often comes with event-based or year-end fundraising. For organizations trying to build predictable cash flow, this is a major business lesson, not just a fundraising tactic.

Another highlight of the discussion is Lauren’s advice on donor segmentation. Rather than grouping supporters only by gift size, she encourages nonprofits to think about behavior, loyalty, interests, and motivations. That shift can help even smaller organizations communicate in more personal and effective ways. As Lauren says, “Even if you only have 200 donors, they’re not all the same.”

The duo also talk about the 80 /20 communication rule, where most donor communication should focus on impact and connection rather than constant asking. That approach helps organizations move from transactional fundraising to relationship-centered fundraising, which is far more sustainable over time.

Strong donor retention is built through thoughtful systems, timely communication, and habits that make supporters feel seen, valued, and connected to mission results. For nonprofit leaders who want to grow fundraising in a healthier and more strategic way, this conversation offers a terrific roadmap!

00:00:00 Welcome and episode introduction
00:01:48 Meet Lauren Laski from Bloomerang
00:03:16 Bloomerang’s AI tool Penny
00:05:28 The 48 hour gratitude rule
00:10:34 Why recurring giving is retention gold
00:13:40 Segmenting donors by behavior not just dollars
00:18:04 The 80 20 donor communication rule
00:20:49 How often major donors should hear from you
00:23:40 Aligning fundraising and marketing teams
00:27:14 Lauren’s GiveCon invitation and final takeaways

Find us Live daily on YouTube!

Find us Live daily on LinkedIn!

Find us Live daily on X: @Nonprofit_Show

Our national co-hosts and amazing guests discuss management, money and missions of nonprofits!
12:30pm ET 11:30am CT 10:30am MT 9:30am PT

Send us your ideas for Show Guests or Topics: [e-mail]
Visit us on the web:The Nonprofit Show