America’s Oldest Panic: Immigration as a Political Weapon

Think America’s current immigration freak-out is some unprecedented modern breakdown?

Nope. It’s one of our oldest political habits. In this episode of Past Is Prologue, John walks through the “greatest hits” of American immigration panic — from 1798 and the Alien & Sedition Acts, to the Know-Nothings, Chinese exclusion, the 1920s quota system, post–World War II crackdowns, the 1965 pivot, and the modern era where immigration stays permanently “unsolved” because an unsolved problem is a renewable political weapon.

The point: these panics are never just about immigration. They’re about power — who gets to define what “America” is, whose culture counts, whose labor is welcomed when it’s cheap, and whose presence becomes a “crisis” the moment it becomes politically useful. If you’ve ever wondered why America keeps replaying the same immigration fights — and why the people shouting the loudest never seem interested in solving anything — this episode lays out the pattern clearly.

🎧 Prefer audio? Search “How the HELL Did We Get Here?” anywhere you get podcasts. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/how-the-hell-did-we-get-here/id1765781522 Please subscribe: https://www.youtube.com/@HowtheHellDidWeGetHerePodcast/videos?sub_confirmation=1 Chapters (locked to transcript)

📌 CHAPTERS 00:00 — Cold open: America’s oldest panic button 01:38 — What this episode covers 02:19 — 1790s setup: fragile republic, France/Britain, factions 06:06 — Alien & Sedition Acts: “national security” as pretext 08:10 — 1840s–50s: Irish/German immigration and the Know-Nothings 10:56 — Religion + culture as the real fuel 12:45 — Chinese immigration, panic, and exclusion 14:21 — Chinese Exclusion Act: race becomes federal law 17:06 — 1890s–1920s: empire, WWI, “storm-cellar isolationism” 19:41 — Red Scare + immigrants as “foreign subversion” 21:21 — Immigration Act of 1924: quotas and “dead-bolting the entryway” 22:57 — WWII and labor demand: Bracero Program 23:58 — Operation Wetback and mid-century whiplash 24:49 — 1965: new system, new backlash 27:29 — 2000s–present: permanent crisis politics 28:24 — Trump era + family separation 31:30 — The pattern, takeaways, and closing

#AmericanHistory #Immigration #USHISTORY #PastIsPrologue #HistoryPodcast #immigrationpolicy #ChineseExclusionAct #KnowNothings #AlienAndSeditionActs #ImmigrationAct1924 #1965ImmigrationAct #LaborHistory #PoliticalHistory #culturalhistory #RaceAndPolitics #HistoryExplained #Education #educational #history #historyfacts #podcast