Almost Cast: The Broadway What-Ifs

Send us a text

Ever wonder what Broadway history could have looked like? In this week’s episode, Mark and Amy spill the tea on all the what-ifs and almosts—diving into the stars who turned down some of the most iconic roles in musical theatre history. 😱

From powerhouse performers who almost defied gravity to legends who passed on parts that later won Tonys, we reimagine what these shows would have been like with a totally different cast. Who said no? Why did they pass? And would the roles have had the same magic?

Get ready for a whirlwind of behind-the-scenes buzz, wild speculation, and our signature bestie banter as we ask the ultimate question: Would Broadway ever be the same? 🎤✨