All About Eve

Peter and Andrew examine Joseph Mankiewicz's 1950 masterpiece All About Eve, exploring how this dialogue-driven drama about ambition and betrayal in the theater world remains timelessly relevant. They analyze the film's sharp wit, discuss the legendary performances that earned four female Oscar nominations, and examine how the story's themes of aging, power, and manipulation transcend its Broadway setting.

In their remake scenarios, they tackle a structural challenge: How do you update a dialogue-heavy classic? Could it work as a High School Musical-style family film? What would a no-budget version focus on? Would it work better as a modern TV series exploring social media fame versus traditional Hollywood? Plus, they discuss the film's influence on countless imitators.

The hosts also share their current viewing habits, including Dumb and Dumber and Avatar: Fire and Ash, while referencing May December, Saltburn, Braveheart, Mean Girls, Showgirls, The Substance, and various backstage dramas in their analysis.

Topics covered: Broadway vs. Hollywood prestige, the evolution of female roles in cinema, dialogue-driven storytelling, the cyclical nature of fame and replacement, and Greek myths.