After the Method Wars - From Ideology to Application in Dog Training

Dog training has entered a new era.

The field has moved past coercion - not because coercion failed to change behavior, but because it failed to meet modern standards of welfare, reliability, and risk.

That part is not controversial anymore.

What is happening now is a lag between where the science is, and what people still see online and at their local training facilities.

There, dogs are somehow still being shocked, yanked, physically manipulated, traumatized, and pushed through behavior under pressure, without the ability to freely learn.

In practice, training today is evaluated on different criteria than it was 20 years ago.

Professionals today look at emotional durability.

We look at stress recovery.

Does the dog generalize?

What are the long term outcomes of our efforts?

We're not looking at whether or not the behavior just stopped, but whether the dog actually learns something that holds up across environments, because dogs don't perform behaviors in isolation.

They bring their nervous systems with them, they bring their history with them, and they bring context with them.

And when we account for that, certain approaches simply do not age well.

That's why the modern version of behavior change emphasizes skills that survive pressure - skills that don't depend on constant management or tools to function.

It's also why the conversation has shifted away from ideology, and towards application.

How do we build responses that remain intact under stress?

How do we actually reduce fallout, instead of managing it later?

These aren't philosophical questions anymore. They're operational ones.

So when people frame this as an ongoing “method war” they're usually arguing with a version of the animal training field that no longer exists at the top.

The work now isn't convincing institutions. It's translating what institutions already agree on into everyday training that people can actually see and use.

That's where we are, and the needle has clearly moved.

And now it's time to do the work that comes next.

Join the Dog Training Revolution and learn more at zakgeorge.com