Adam Clatworthy, Emma Baple, Jo Wright, Lisa Beaton and Jamie Ellingford: What Does the Diagnostic Odyssey Really Mean for Families?

In this special episode, recorded live at the 2025 Genomics England Research Summit, host Adam Clatworthy is joined by parents, clinicians and researchers to explore the long, uncertain and often emotional journey to a genetic diagnosis. Together, they go behind the science to share what it means to live with uncertainty, how results like variants of uncertain significance (VUS) are experienced by families, and why communication and support matter just as much as genomic testing and research. The panel discuss the challenges families face when a diagnosis remains out of reach, the role of research in refining and revisiting results over time, and how collaboration between researchers, clinicians and participants could help shorten diagnostic journeys in the future. Joining Adam Clatworthy, Vice-Chair for the Participant Panel, on this episode are: Emma Baple – Clinical geneticist and Medical Director, South West Genomic Laboratory Hub Jamie Ellingford – Lead genomic data scientist, Genomics England Jo Wright – Member of the Participant Panel and Parent Representative for SWAN UK Lisa Beaton - Member of the Participant Panel and Parent Representative for SWAN UK Linked below are the episodes mentioned in the episode: What is the diagnostic odyssey? What is a Variant of Uncertain Significance? You can download the transcript, or read it below. Sharon: Hello, and welcome to Behind the Genes. My name is Sharon Jones and today we’re bringing you a special episode recorded live from our Research Summit held in June this year. The episode features a panel conversation hosted by Adam Clatworthy, Vice-Chair of the Participant Panel. Our guests explore navigating the diagnostic odyssey, the often-complex journey to reaching a genetic diagnosis. If you’d like to know more about what the diagnostic odyssey is, check our bitesize explainer episode, ‘What is the Diagnostic Odyssey?’ linked in the episode description. In today’s episode you may hear our guests refer to ‘VUS’ which stands for a variant of uncertain significance. This is when a genetic variant is identified, but its precise impact is not yet known. You can learn more about these in another one of our explainer episodes, “What is a Variant of Uncertain Significance?” And now over to Adam. -- Adam: Welcome, everyone, thanks for joining this session. I’m always really humbled by the lived experiences and the journeys behind the stories that we talk about at these conferences, so I’m really delighted to be hosting this panel session. It’s taking us behind the science, it’s really focusing on the people behind the data and the lived experiences of all the individuals and the families who are really navigating this system, trying to find answers and really aiming to get a diagnosis – that has to be the end goal. We know it’s not the silver bullet, but it has to be the goal so that everyone can get that diagnosis and get that clarity and what this means for their medical care moving forwards. So, today we’re really going to aim to demystify what this diagnostic odyssey is, challenging the way researchers and clinicians often discuss long diagnostic journeys, and we’ll really talk about the vital importance of research in improving diagnoses, discussing the challenges that limit the impact of emerging research for families on this odyssey and the opportunities for progress. So, we’ve got an amazing panel here. Rather than me trying to introduce you, I think it’s great if you could just introduce yourselves, and Lisa, I’ll start with you. Lisa: Hi, I’m Lisa Beaton and I am the parent of a child with an unknown, thought to be neuromuscular, disease. I joined the patient Participant Panel 2 years ago now and I’m also a Parent Representative for SWAN UK, which stands of Syndromes Without A Name. I have 4 children who have all come with unique and wonderful bits and pieces, but it’s our daughter who’s the most complicated. Adam: Thank you. Over to you, Jo. Jo: Hi, I’m Jo Wright, I am the parent of a child with an undiagnosed genetic condition. So I’ve got an 11-year-old daughter. 100,000 Genomes gave us a VUS, which we’re still trying to find the research for and sort of what I’ll talk about in a bit. And I’ve also got a younger daughter. I joined the Participant Panel just back in December. I’m also a Parent Rep for SWAN UK, so Lisa and I have known each other for quite a while through that. Adam: Thank you, Jo. And, Jamie, you’re going to be covering both the research and the clinician side and you kind of wear 2 hats, so, yeah, over to you. Jamie: Hi, everyone, so I’m Jamie Ellingford and, as Adam alluded to, I’m fortunate and I get to wear 2 hats. So, one of those hats is that I’m Lead Genomic Data Scientist for Rare Disease at Genomics England and so work as part of a really talented team of scientists and ...