98 | 5 Mistakes That Quietly Kill Goat Herd Profitability

Breeding decisions, feed calculations, replacement standards, and herd focus all shape profitability but rarely in dramatic ways. Most goat herds don’t fall apart overnight. They slowly lose momentum because of small management decisions that compound over time.

In this episode, I walk through five mistakes that can quietly erode profitability in a goat herd. From breeding does too early to failing to track does exposed to breeding, feeding without running the math, and keeping goats out of sentiment, we break down the practical decisions that either strengthen or weaken your system.

You’ll hear how delayed breeding improved longevity in our forage-based herd, why exposed-doe metrics give a more honest fertility picture, how simple feed calculations can prevent waste and overconditioning, and how tightening replacement standards shapes long-term herd direction. I also share the hard decision we made to focus fully on commercial meat goats when our goals became clearer.

The goal isn’t perfection, it’s intentional management.

If you’ve been working hard but feel like your herd isn’t progressing the way it should, this episode will help you step back, evaluate your system, and tighten the areas that matter most.

In This Episode, I Cover:

• Why breeding does at the wrong stage of development increases replacement pressure
• How delayed breeding improved longevity and reduced kidding problems in our herd
• Why tracking “does exposed to breeding” gives a more accurate fertility picture
• The importance of measuring singles, twins, triplets, and assistance rates
• How to calculate feed intake using body weight and dry matter percentages
• Why protein is the most expensive nutrient you feed
• How overconditioning affects breed-up
• The long-term cost of keeping goats for emotional reasons
• Why tightening replacement standards improves herd direction
• How unclear production goals create inconsistent selection decisions

Key Takeaways:

• Longevity is profit
• Fertility must be measured honestly to improve
• Feed efficiency requires both math and observation
• Replacement standards should tighten over time
• Sentiment has a cost — acknowledge it
• Clear production goals drive consistent herd improvement
• Small management decisions compound over years

Related Episodes:

• 22 | What Is the Perfect Meat Goat? How to Choose the Right Breed for Your Farm or Homestead PART 1
• 23 | Boer vs Kiko, What Meat Goat Breed is the Best Fit for Your Farm or Homestead? PART 2
• 27 | Which Goats Should I Keep for Breeding? How to Select Replacement Does and Plan Your Goat Breeding Season
• 29 | Are Your Goats Too Fat or Too Thin? How to Body Condition Score and Adjust Your Feeding Strategy for Healthier Goats
• 68 | New to Raising Livestock? Risk Management Strategies When the Learning Curve is Steep

All the Best, Millie

Resources & Links:

• Leave a review on Apple Podcasts + grab the free Kidding Due Date Chart: https://www.getgoatwise.com/kidding-chart
• Get Dry Creek meat: https://drycreekheritagemeats.com
• Join my insider email list: https://www.getgoatwise.com/insider
• Join the free community: https://www.getgoatwise.com/community
• Email me: [e-mail]
• See ranch life on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/drycreekpastures/

Disclaimer:

The information shared in this episode is for educational purposes only and should not be considered veterinary advice. Always consult a licensed veterinarian for animal health guidance.