#611 Is Ireland Forcing Mothers to Identify the Father?

Niall opens the phone lines to hear mixed views on Ireland’s new birth registration law, which for the first time places a duty on unmarried parents to provide the father’s details when registering a child’s birth. The legislation, which came into effect in December 2025, is intended to give children greater access to information about their biological parents — but it has sparked strong and divided reactions.

Callers weigh in on whether the change is a positive step for children’s rights and identity, or an unnecessary intrusion into private family circumstances. Some welcome the move as long overdue, arguing that children have a right to know where they come from and that fathers should be encouraged to take responsibility. Others raise concerns about women’s safety, privacy, and the emotional impact in complex or difficult relationships, even with exemptions built into the law.

Niall explores what the legislation does — and doesn’t — do, including the fact that providing a father’s details does not automatically grant guardianship or legal rights. Is the balance right between children’s rights and mothers’ autonomy? Are the safeguards strong enough? And could there be unintended consequences?

A thoughtful, caller-led conversation on family, responsibility, and how the State should navigate sensitive personal realities.