#55 The 5" food rule: safe to eat? Or misguided?

Send us a text

Be honest—have you ever rescued a French fry from the floor? In this bite-size myth episode, I test the famous “5-second rule.” I walk through what actually transfers to your food (fast), when that matters, and why a little microbial exposure isn’t always the villain—while drawing a hard line for high-risk settings and situations.

Key Topics & Takeaways

• The verdict meter: The 5-second rule is false—bacteria can transfer in <1 second. In a Rutgers lab study, juicy foods like watermelon picked up the most, gummies the least; tile/steel transferred more than carpet (Applied and Environmental Microbiology / PubMed
  ).
• Foodborne illness is common: ~48M illnesses/year in the U.S., ~128k hospitalizations, ~3k deaths. Usual suspects include Salmonella, E. coli, Campylobacter, Listeria, and norovirus. Symptoms are typically GI, but severe cases occur—especially in the very young, elderly, pregnant, or immunocompromised (CDC overview
  ).
• Context matters: Moisture and surface trump “time.” High-moisture foods collect more microbes; visibly dirty or high-traffic floors (think convenience stores) raise risk—regardless of seconds.
• When to skip the floor food—no debate: If you’re immunocompromised, pregnant, very young/elderly, or you’re in a hospital/clinical setting, don’t eat it. Full stop.
• Nuance: Are microbes always bad? Early, diverse exposure to benign environmental microbes associates with more resilient immunity. Farm-exposed kids had lower asthma/atopy rates (≈20–40%) versus city peers (NEJM
  ). Greening urban daycare yards (adding soil/plant matter) increased skin/gut microbial diversity and shifted immune markers in a favorable direction (Science Advances
  ). This doesn’t mean “eat off the floor”—it means the bigger story is about exposure diversity and context.
• My practice: At home, I don’t stress over a quick drop on a clean surface; out in public or medical settings, I pass.

Bottom Line
Microbes hop on fast; the “rule” doesn’t save you. But danger depends on what fell, where, and who is eating it. Be smart, especially if you or your environment are higher risk.

Call to Action
What health saying should I myth-test next? Text me your favorites (include your email so I can reply), and please rate the show on Apple/Spotify. Want my newsletter on practical, science-backed longevity? Join me at DrBobbyLiveLongAndWell.com.