13: Faith Healing Gone Wrong – The Schaible Case

🎧 Episode Title: Faith Healing Gone Wrong – The Schaible Case

Welcome to another gripping and emotional episode of Heinous Beliefs the podcast where we expose the darkest crimes ever committed under the influence of religious and ideological beliefs. In this episode, we’re diving deep into the tragic and preventable deaths of two young children, Kent and Brandon Schaible, whose lives were cut short not by violence or disease but by the faith-driven decisions of their parents.

Herbert and Catherine Schaible were followers of a radical faith-healing church in Philadelphia. Instead of taking their children to the doctor, they turned to prayer and laid hands, believing that divine intervention would do what modern medicine could. Spoiler alert: it didn’t. Twice. And what’s worse? The system gave them a second chance… and they still chose faith over help.

🔍 In This Episode, We Break Down:

• The Background of Herbert & Catherine Schaible: What kind of parents were they? What were they like behind closed doors? We give you a full character breakdown based on verified public records, court documents, and news reports.
  
  
• The First Century Gospel Church: An isolated, tight-knit congregation led by Pastor Nelson A. Clark. We look at the toxic doctrine that banned all forms of medicine and glorified suffering as a sign of faith.
  
  
• The Death of Kent Schaible (2009): How a treatable illness turned fatal under the weight of blind religious conviction and how the legal system responded.
  
  
• The Death of Brandon Schaible (2013): How the exact same tragedy happened again just four years later despite court orders and probation conditions that were meant to prevent it.
  
  
• Religious Exemption Laws: How Pennsylvania (and over 30 other states) once had child welfare loopholes that allowed parents to opt out of life-saving care in the name of religion.
  
  
• The Public Outrage and Legislative Fallout: We talk about how these cases shifted public opinion, inspired nationwide media coverage, and led to calls for major policy reform.
  
  
• The Bigger Picture: Why this isn’t just about one family. This is about how deeply-held beliefs, when protected by outdated systems, can become a recipe for tragedy and how many more children are at risk if we don’t have hard conversations about the line between belief and harm.
  
  

⚠️ Content Warning

This episode includes discussions of child death, religious extremism, faith-based medical neglect, and disturbing court testimony. Please use discretion when listening.

📢 Let’s Keep the Conversation Going

Have thoughts about this case? Wanna share your personal story or tip us off to another crime driven by belief?

We want to hear from YOU.

📧 Email: [e-mail]
📸 Instagram: @heinousbeliefs

DMs are open. Emails are welcome. And if you’re a survivor of this kind of religious abuse or know someone who is we’re listening, and we believe you.

🖤 Support the Show

If this episode moved you, angered you, or made you think a little deeper share it. Leave us a 5-star review. Screenshot it and tag us on social media. Every share helps break the silence around religious trauma and exposes how harmful belief systems can fly under the radar for years.

Want to go the extra mile?

• Send the episode to a friend.
  
  
• Share your favorite quote on IG.
  
  
• Use the hashtag #HeinousBeliefs to join the discussion.
  
  

We’re building a community of truth-tellers, survivors, and thinkers—and you’re a part of it now.