1.18: Jingle All The Way/The Santa Clause: There’s a Sale at the Fashion Boutique (Holiday Contest #2)

Brian and Steph dive sleigh-first into the season with a Pop ’n Poss Hess Jingle before breaking down the Christmas classics Jingle All the Way and The Santa Clause. They relive the wild ’90s toy crazes (Furbies, Tickle Me Elmo—send help), reminisce about their best childhood gifts, and confess the worst ones they ever received. Brian shares his grandma’s iconic habit of returning gifts she didn’t like, the hosts debate gift budgets and whether gift cards count as “lazy,” and they question if it’s finally time to retire the White Elephant exchange. (Do we really need another Bluetooth speaker?) Steph wraps it all up with her official take on what is and isn’t acceptable holiday gift wrapping. Cozy up and enjoy!