Winter in Madrid

De: C. J. Sansom

Narrado por: Gordon Gordon

Winter in Madrid is set just after the bloody Spanish Civil War, with World War II looming over Europe. Reluctantly, Harry Brett looks for an old schoolmate who's become a person of interest for British intelligence.©2006 C.J. Sansom (P)2006 Recorded Books, LLC

Reseñas de la Crítica

"The playing fields of Rookwood did little to prepare reluctant spy Harry Brett for the moral no man's land of post-Civil War Spain that awaits him in this cinematic historical thriller from British author Sansom....But those halcyon days have made him one of the few people likely to win the confidence of fellow old boy Sandy Forsyth, now a shady Madrid businessman, Franco associate and object of intense curiosity to British intelligence. Despite his reservations, Brett - whose best friend from Rookwood, Bernie Piper, disappeared in Spain a few years earlier while battling Franco with the International Brigade - accepts the assignment as his duty, and almost as swiftly regrets it. For the Madrid he finds has become a mockery of the vibrant, hopeful place he and Bernie visited during the dawn of the Republic. As in his Matthew Shardlake mystery series set in Tudor London, Sansom deftly plots his politically charged tale for maximal suspense, all the way up to its stunning conclusion. A bestseller in the U.K., this moving opus leaves the reader mourning for the Spain that might have been - and the England that maybe never was. ( Publishers Weekly)

Great plot - good historical mystery - exciting action

Realistic well developed characters. Excellent description of details - the reader was quite good - on par with the authors other books

war weary and bleak

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

If I were only interested in the Spanish Civil War it would have been fantastic fiction. I thought that I was reading about espionage. This was more political than espionage. Worn torn Spain was the main character. If I had known that I would not have listenened to the book.

What was your reaction to the ending? (No spoilers please!)

I hated it but understood it.

Have you listened to any of Gordon Gordon’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

He was excellent.

Did Winter in Madrid inspire you to do anything?

to be more careful in what I listen too. Mr Sansom's other series was fantastic. I liked espionage and thought that was what I was getting. I feel misled.

Any additional comments?

The main characters, two out of three, were weak and not that interesting. This is a book about the atrocity that was the Spanish Civil War. As a historical document it is probably excellent.
I was looking for escapist fiction and clearly picked the wrong novel.

Shardlake fans will be disappointed

The very negative reviews of this book might well be the result of the jarring difference in style, tone, and narrative from the Shardlake series. Winter in Madrid is written in a literary style" with a weak plot, third person narration, flashbacks, and a generally bleak mood. As a fan of the Shardlake series I was unpleasantly surprised by all of the above. I wouldn't consider Winter in Madrid to be a failure or a bad novel, but it was neither what I expected or enjoyed. For anyone interested in the Spanish Civil War I would recommend Orwell's Homage to Catalonia.

Characters tossed by history

Wonderful glimpse into a time and place I didn’t know much about — Spain during its Civil War and the factions competing for influence during World War II. Some of our characters are driven by principles (political or moral), others by greed, others just tossed by forces beyond their control. We see how they got where they are and part of where they go next, but the end result neither is tidy nor gives a sense that things in real life are ever resolved for good…

Not Sansom's Best

Any additional comments?

I bought this because I like Sansom's Matthew Shardlake stories. This is not as good. Alan Furst does this genre much better.

Worth the slow start

I came to this novel once I finished Sansom’s Shardlake series. For that reason, it took some time to become invested in this story as it’s nothing like Shardlake. However the writing was just as good so I persevered. So glad I did! I really enjoyed it. Learning about the Franco regime was quite eye opening.

should have bought it sooner

I had this on my wish list for years because I'm a big fan of the Matthew Shardlake series. I wanted to listen to a book about Spain and Franco, but a review or two had some negative comments leading me to hesitate. I now forget what those reviewers' gripes were, but I found the book to be wonderful. A good story, interesting characters, and well performed.

realistic characters in historical context

I have read all of CJ Sansom's mysteries set in/around the reign of Henry VIII and the establishment of the Church of England. i enjoyed the historical context and mystery plot. I was a bit hesitant to purchase Winter in Madrid as I did not know what to expect in terms of treatment of the very diverse and violent political movements of the time. I found the book to be quite enjoyable because of Sansom's creation of characters who are not perfect, but are wrestling either with post-war apathy or their pre-conceived notions of the "right" political stance. the story does not have a nice, "happy ever after ending", but this too is in keeping with the times. I enjoyed learning more about Spain's history both pre and post WWII as part of the plot development, and it has prompted me to take on some non-fiction reading of Franco and England's and France's role in keeping an authoritarian, rightist regime in power at the expense of the less wealthy/connected members of the society. Morally questionable?, that's for each person to decide, but pragmatically - it almost always comes back to kick you in the teeth (Shah- Iran; Allende-Chile...the list goes on). an enjoyable, and thoughtful read.

historical mystery/thriller at its best.

Fascinsting period of Spanish history often overshadowed by the events of ww1 and ww2. Well written with a carefully constructed suspensful climax with many surprises. I enjoyed this book immensely.

Grim is an understatement

Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?

I would not recommend this book to anyone who I considered a friend without giving them the contact information for the local suicide hotline. The story was extremely depressing and really didn't need to be.

What was most disappointing about C. J. Sansom’s story?

The ending was unreasonably sad. The main character had a bittersweet life which continued to sour. Sansom could have let him have some happiness at least.

Have you listened to any of Gordon Gordon’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

I don't think I have heard him perform before, but he was magnificent.

Did Winter in Madrid inspire you to do anything?

Yes. It inspired me to not read Dominion. If Sansom writes another Shardlake mystery, however, I will give it a shot. I have listened to all of those--that's the only reason I bothered with Winter in Madrid.

Any additional comments?

Sansom is a skilled writer whose ability to paint with words is marvelous. If I were to see any of his characters on the street I feel sure I would recognize them--they seem that clear and that real. His works are exceptionally well researched and very true to the period and events he tries to capture. The plots are excellent, including the one for this book. This book starts a little slow, but there was a lot of groundwork to lay. The pace picks up at the end of part one and he builds suspense steadily until the end. I just hated to see the story end with such despair and lack of hope, especially for Harry--I couldn't help but feel that he might have been better off to have died at Dunkirk.