The Shadow Lines

De: Amitav Ghosh

Narrado por: Raj Varma

Duración: 10 h y 2 m

Resumen del Editor

Opening in Calcutta in the 1960s, Ghosh’s radiant second novel follows two families - one English, one Bengali - as their lives intertwine in tragic and comic ways. The narrator, Indian-born and English educated, traces events back and forth in time, through years of Bengali partition and violence, observing the ways in which political events invade private lives.

©2005 Amitav Ghosh (P)2010 Brilliance Audio, Inc.

Reseñas de la Crítica

"A stunning novel, a rare work that balances formal ingenuity, heart, and mind.” ( New Republic)

Narrator Doesn't Know How to Pronounce

Though an Indian narrator has been selected for this book, it is remarkable how little he knows how to pronounce Indian words. For instance, the final vowel sound in "Ballygunj" is rendered "oo" rather than the schwa sound it ought to be. Similarly, the vowel in Sena (as in the medieval eastern Indian Sena dynasty), is pronounced as "ee" rather than "ay" (as in "say" or "bay"). And there are innumerable other more or less egregious instances of a similar lack of linguistic familiarity with the world described (and the Bengali that lies behind the author's English). This could have been remedied, of course, by a bit of research. Or, better, a native Calcuttan Bengali might have been found, which would have been easy enough.
The listening experience is not wholly compromised, but it is remarkable how little thought seems to go into the choice of narrators of Indian English novels. The rating is for the audiobook as a book.

Performance

Narrator had an affected British accent, an affectation that was a bit annoying to listen to even when using common Indian words.
It distracted from appreciating the story unfortunately.

Excellent narrator. Master story teller.

Raj Varma's narration enhanced the experience of listening to a master story teller. His voice was fresh, appropriately nuanced and a pleasure to listen to. As always, Amitav Ghosh depicted characters with depth and sympathy. It is an old fashioned family tale and an exploration about what creates a family narrative and history. I thoroughly enjoyed this audio book. I would have given 4.5 or 4.75 stars if possible.

A more personal novel

What was one of the most memorable moments of The Shadow Lines?

One of the scenes I remember most clearly was when Ila (spelling) undressed in front of the narrator and how the narrator was no longer able to hide his interest in Ila.

Which character – as performed by Raj Varma – was your favorite?

I think the character I got the strongest sense of was the narrator's grandmother. Varma gives you a real sense of her strength, her resolve, and her quiet nature.

Any additional comments?

I became familiar with Ghosh in his grander, more sweeping stories (such as The Glass Palace, The Sea of Poppies, etc). This story feels much smaller and more personal than those narratives, and that might be because this story has an "I" narrator rather than an unseen 3rd point of view. The scale of events in also smaller as it is not talking about events with truly international impacts as seen in the previously mentioned book. That said, you still have a rich cast of characters and an immersive shifting story.