The Mystery of Edwin Drood – A Farce with a Eucatastrophic Ending

The Mystery of Edwin Drood – A Farce with a Eucatastrophic Ending
by Radu I. Comșuța

Charles Dickens’s The Mystery of Edwin Drood remains one of literature’s great unfinished puzzles. The novel breaks off mid-story, leaving readers to ask: what happened to Edwin Drood, and what did Dickens intend? For more than a century and a half, scholars and writers have debated clues, proposed endings, and staged mock trials to solve the case.

In this bold and original contribution, Radu I. Comșuța enters the debate with a work that is at once literary criticism, parody, and imaginative continuation. This farce is not a solemn reconstruction of Dickens’s plan, nor a simple pastiche. It is an experiment in creative criticism that uses humor, irony, and intertextual play to reimagine the characters of Cloisterham while remaining true to Dickens’s moral universe.

The book’s distinctive key is the Tolkienian idea of “eucatastrophe” – the sudden joyous turn that restores meaning at the brink of despair. Applied to Dickens’s mystery, it yields a resolution that is surprising yet coherent. John Jasper, long treated as the inevitable villain, is reconsidered as a figure capable of metanoia; Neville Landless, too often misread as mere rival, becomes a witness to reconciliation; and Edwin himself, far from being only victim or rumor, emerges as a catalyst of narrative transformation.

The result is a theatrical ending that both parodies detective clichés and reflects seriously on how stories close—not in darkness, but in sudden light. With erudition and wit, Comșuța invites us to laugh, reflect, and rethink what “closure” can mean in fiction.

• For Dickensians: a fresh, well-argued contribution to Droodian studies.
• 
  
• For new readers: an accessible, entertaining entry point into one of Victorian fiction’s most intriguing enigmas.
• 
  
• For lovers of story craft: a demonstration of how literature can reinvent itself through farce, parody, and the hope of a eucatastrophic turn.
•