Sherman

Soldier, Realist, American

De: B.H. Liddell Hart

Narrado por: Derek Perkins

A biography of William T. Sherman by the military theorist and author of Scipio Africanus: Greater Than Napoleon.

©1929 The Executors of Lady Liddell Hart, deceased (P)2019 Tantor

A good look at an American Icon

This was an interesting book on Sherman.

I picked it up due to my reading of Ryan Holiday's "Ego is the Enemy", and I was expecting a more comprehensive biography of one of the most underrated figures of the Civil War.

This is a more in-depth look at the Civil War with a little bit of the before and after of Sherman's life. However, overall, it is a surprisingly engaging book that really delves into the mind of W.T. Sherman.

Excellent evaluation of the growth of a person

Lidell-Hart’s revealing of Sherman’s growth as a general and person was outstanding. His own personal experience as a soldier gave him the ability to recognize Sherman’s genius not only as a military strategist but also as a psychologist.

New insights from am old tome

It’s an amazing thing to get a fresh perspective by reaching back nearly a century. Yet Hart’s insights are timeless and contain points not seen in numerous extant Sherman biographies which continue to churn out the same ideas that have been hashed over many times. Additionally, Hart’s broad, deep knowledge of military history affords many comparisons with campaigns past, and allows for analysis of strategy rather than simple recounting of events. However, his treatment of Sherman’s post-war life, which contains many interesting events, is rather thin.

I get it — a British author requires a British reader. But the listening would’ve been much easier to understand had an American been recruited for the US edition of this book, eliminating differing pronunciation and accent.

Recommended for those who want deeper understanding of Sherman’s life and times.

Focused story of Sherman and outstanding narrator

Although written in another era, nearly 100 years ago, in language that we don't use today, I found this portrayal of Sherman to be riveting. I have read several books about Grant and the battles in the west in which he and Sherman were engaged. I have a natural interest since I have a g-g grandfather who served in Sherman's armies from Corinth through Missionary Ridge. Hart's narrative is lucid and clear. He cites Sherman's correspondence extensively and places the campaigns and battles in the context of the wider war. It helped me that I already had more detailed background on the course of events since this is not a detailed battle book. Liddell Hart is unabashed in his respect for Sherman. As such, Sherman's vilifiers will not find this book as engaging and rewarding as I did. If half of it is accurate, which is certainly an understatement, Sherman was a remarkable individual.

As always, Derek Perkins is simply the best. He can narrate every audio book I listen to and I will be happy. I recently listened to a book about Tesla that could have used his voice.

A Must Read!!!

Loved this book. I am from Lancaster, OH so it was fantastic to read a book about such a renowned figure from my hometown. Sherman was a giant of his age and any lover of military history and strategy will love this fascinating and detailed review of his life and career with only scant opinion. The narrator does a great job of being easily understood while maintaining the mood of each section without putting you to sleep. There are even some parts of high brow comedy, masterfully derived by the writer from Sherman's correspondence and memoirs. Highly recommend!

B.H. Liddel Hart is a fine historian indeed. Great narration as well.

This book takes a deep look into the mind of Sherman. More than just a tactical overview, this work of art is a masterpiece.

Perfect performance for an American icon

Derek Perkins gives another outstanding performance, and thankfully he was selected as the narrator for this biography of William Tecumseh Sherman, the brilliant Civil War General who was instrumental in bringing the war to an end. Sherman grew into his role and developed his tactics and strategy of diversion and troop movement. For this strategy he saved the lives of his troops by avoiding confrontation, yet achieving his goals. This is an inspiring and illustrating biography. It was hard to put dow. Unlike Robert O’Connell’s biography, Hart’s is dominated by meticulous descriptions of battles, such as the march to Savannah. This is more of a military history than O’Connell’s which delves into Sherman’s family dynamic and other affairs away from the battle, such as his matriculation at West Point and commands before the Civil War. Hart is battle concentrated and Perkins’ commanding voice dominates the telling of Sherman’s story.

Deep dive

Be prepared this is a very deep look into Schoellman and his campaigns. There are times when it gets kind of bogged down with the details of the different campaigns and to listen to it once you’re not going to be able to comprehend all of it. I was kind of hoping for something a little more Sherman specific. But you definitely give a very good feel for how he did what he did and perhaps a little of what he was thinking.

Well written, well read

Hart was clearly a master scholar who’s writing showed a delight in the scholarship and subject of this giant of modern military history, Sherman.

The narrator did a great job reading it making a great combo.

Excellent

Great insight to a great man, and sheds new light (at least to me) on the "March to the Sea"