Report from Ground Zero

De: Dennis Smith

Narrado por: Eric Conger, Jeff David, Don Leslie

Duración: 6 h y 56 m

Resumen del Editor

Immediately after two hijacked jets struck the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001, Dennis Smith volunteered in the rescue effort. Having spent his career as both a respected writer and a member of one of the city's busiest firehouses, Smith became determined to use his unique background to tell the story of the disaster and its aftermath with the empathy and understanding that only an insider could bring to it.

Smith has collected astonishing first-person testimony from rescuers who were present as the towers were attacked, evacuated, and then fell. He also recounts his own experiences at the devastation of Ground Zero over the next few weeks: attending to the physically and psychologically wounded, helping organize fund-raising, and attending some of the almost inconceivable number of funerals of firefighters, police officers, and emergency rescue workers.

Report from Ground Zero is the most detailed and immediate record of this unforgettable event, with the unique perspective of a writer who has been praised as "the poet laureate of firefighters".

©2002 Dennis Smith. Recorded by arrangement with Viking Penguin, a division of Penguin Putnam Inc. (P)2002 HighBridge Company

Reseñas de la Crítica

"The narrators recreate these emotional interviews with accounts of the horror suffered by these survivors while simultaneously revealing their unselfish acts of heroism under the extreme conditions of war on our own soil. With dignity and respect, the narratives reveal heartbroken yet courageous individuals who instinctively manifested a fighting spirit of good vs. evil, as well as love for their fellow humans. This is a tragic yet inspirational testimony well performed in light of the still fresh memory." (AudioFile)

Gut Wrenching Intensity Well written

A collection of first person accounts of the events after the WTC attack written by a member of the NYFD and previiously published author. Includes accounts of others.

All these years later this book rekindles the intensity of the tragedy of the attacks on the World Trade Center. Although most is the recollections of the author, it includes other first person accounts.

The book is not about who to blame, how it might have been prevented but rather focuses on what happened that day and the many days that followed as the NYFD dealt with both the destruction and fires and then the massive loss of life of their brother firefighters and police in the collapse of the twin towers and the following efforts to absorb the losses and sift through the rubble for their lost teammates.

The narration of the Audiobook version was excellent . HIGHLY RECOMMENDED

Gut wrenching

No words can really describe my impressions of this story. It took extra time because I’d have to stop to compose myself between chapters or sections. The author, a former firefighter and now a writer, did a magnificent job.

A raw account of a defining event in our generation

As someone who was in emergency services during 9-11, I watched the towers fall on television. It wasn’t until years later that I absorbed the impact of this catastrophe. While much of 9-11 focused on the emergency services workers in NYC, and deservingly so, so many civilians were affected by this event. And so many came together to unite America.

What I liked about this book were the stories of several people involved, some in the towers and some who were not.

I disliked that this book wasn’t longer. More stories from all involved.

I thought the narrators captured the emotion of those who told their story. I don’t think performances were “over the top.” There are times when emergency service workers seem callous to death and destruction, but they must be that way to keep control and give direction. It is only later, when adrenaline has subsided, that those same emergency service workers weep, or unfortunately, turn to a bottle.

Having visited Ground Zero and the 9-11 Museum, this books helps put things into perspective that I saw there and the stories I read.

This book was informative, yet sad. Recommend reading in a quiet place.

NEVER FORGET 343 AND COUNTING

This was an amazing book, documentary. I was a responder part of 1 of the 9 Volunteer Fire Depts of NYC. I was stationed at E259 LIE n Greenpoint ave. 18Hrs and that week part of the Rescue Recovery. This is a great way to show others how we all came together. God bless the FAMILY/FRIENDS of all the 343. GOD BLESS THIS BROTHERHOOD. A day that i will NEVER FORGET.

Very good but...

What was the most compelling aspect of this narrative?

The stories of the firemen who worked at WTC on 9/11 and the months after is very dramatic, and their courage and dedication is fascinating to read about.

What didn’t you like about the narrators’s performance?

Unfortunately the narrator Jeff David is just awful. His voice is hard to listen to and sometimes he goes waaaay overboard trying to make the story more dramatic.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

Lee Ielpi (a fireman, talking about his son Jonathan Ielpi, who was one of the hundreds of firemen lost in the tragedy) really hits you. "I know he's in good hands but i wish he was in my hands"

Heart Full of Love

What can be said but this book has the finest writing and is narrated in such an appropriate, realistic way. Took me back to that day and, though I was out on L.I. and could not help, I felt that, through the eyes of those whose testimonials are offered to me, as a listener, I could live vicariously, and give my love through the actions of those who could help.

Audio book vs Physical book

love this audio book, I listen to it at work all the time.After receiving a physical copy for Christmas this year, I realize there are testimonials in the book that were missing in the audio book.A bit of a disappointment but it doesn't make it an less of a gripping listen or read .

Intersting choice of narrator

The stories are very good. I have to be honest, all this time, I only thought a few people survived the collapse, it seems like many more did which was a great feeling.
The narrator's voice was hard to listen to at times and it was so low and grainy there were times I couldn't understand him.
The second half of the book was a lot less exciting than the first.

Devistating

Would you consider the audio edition of Report from Ground Zero to be better than the print version?

No, the narrator's fake crying came across as over the top and distracting.

What did you like best about this story?

The experience of 9/11 during and after. Hearing what is what like in the pits working the cleanup.

Who would you have cast as narrator instead of the narrators?

Eric Conger's narrating would be better suited for a fictional story instead of biographical books. I think a better narrator would have been Dennis Smith himself. The other narrators were great.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

No extreme reaction because when you choose a 9/11 book, you pretty much know what you are going to be reading about.

Not worth a credit

Not only is this book boring, it seems pretty biased in terms of its portrayal of what it calls "Middle Easterners." Absolutely pales in comparison in to other books about September 11. Don't bother with it.