Lily

The Highland Clan, Book 3

De: Keira Montclair

Narrado por: Paul Woodson

Duración: 7 h y 11 m

Resumen del Editor

Lily Ramsay is the sunshine at the center of the Ramsay clan. Even as a wee lassie, sick with a childhood illness, she had the power to spread smiles and laughter wherever she went. But when Lily's beloved brother marries and becomes laird of the clan, Lily feels lost. Her once steadfast companion has little time for her, and his new wife has assumed the duties she used to carry out for the clan. While she couldn't be happier for her loved ones, she longs for something more for herself. In truth, she longs for her brother's best friend - the braw warrior she's loved all her life.

Kyle Maule has made it his mission to do aught he can to honor his sire's legacy. His appointment as the new Ramsay laird's second is a dream come true, but Lily Ramsay's beauty and irrepressible spirit threaten to make Kyle forget himself and fumble on the job. Desperate to do his duty to his laird and his fallen sire, Kyle tries to quell his feelings for Lily - to protect her without succumbing to the desire to be with her. But Lily is not the sort of lass to be held at arm's length. When an unexpected threat befalls her, Kyle will have to decide to either let her in all the way or step away from her forever.

©2016 Keira Montclair (P)2016 Keira Montclair

exceptional!!!!!!!!<br />

a great story new twists to a highland romance! i love the narration!! im hooked on Montclair books!!!!!!

Love Kyle

So funny, trying so hard to fight against the inevitable, . Lily was indeed special, but Kyle lost his ever loving mind around her. Beautiful story. Love this series!

The Highland Clan Book 3 "Lily" 🌺🛡Enjoyable!!!

The Highland Clan Book 3 "Lily" 🌺🛡
Enjoyable Audio Story 💯👏♥️

I enjoy the Clan Grant & Clan Ramsay story because of the love and intimacy between Lily & Kyle ♥️ and unexpected surprises along the way 🤗. Also, the delightful bonding of Sunshine 🐎 Moonbeam 🐺🐺 and Starlight 🌕🌟

It's also fascinating to hear the narrator character voices through the stories of Clan Grant and Clan Ramsay series. To be one within each soul is absolutely amazing 💯

Looking forward in listening to your next audio book 💯👏♥️🤗🌹🛡⚔️

Funny and Romantic

I have read this book a few times and I am not one who reads books again. It is cute and funny sweet and Romantic. Kyle is dreamy but funny too!

Story...

I like the overall Highland story line but the main characters in this book, Lily and Kyle were a bit weak in substance... Plot was boring and predictable. I like a book with more historical background in balance with the romance. This was my first and only Montclair book, sadly probably last as well.

I Loved this story

What made the experience of listening to Lily the most enjoyable?

The character of Lily is intriguing because she is so ethereal and other-worldly. I loved the way the author maximized those elements and spun a tale that allowed her nature to soar and her to thrive.

What was one of the most memorable moments of Lily?

I personally enjoyed the scene involving Lily and Moonbeam, their first meeting etc. Very touching.

What does Paul Woodson bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

The contribution that Paul Woodson brings to this series is TREMENDOUS!!! his performance is totally awesome. Reading these stories without him removes a dimension of enjoyment that I can scarcely put into words, something akin to black/white vs color. His accent and voice variations are delightfully enjoyable. I am an audio book freak and Paul Woodson is one of my most favorite narrators, easily in the top 5 I have ever heard.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

There are many but the one that comes immediately to mind was when Kyle and Lily pleasured each other at Edinburgh without violating his or her honor.

Disappointing

I absolutely love all of the other books by Keira Montclair, but this one was very disappointing. I couldn't even make it through the whole book. While Lily is very loving and sweet, she seems like a 14 year old. I assume she is supposed to be around 20 years old but she is very whiny and childlike most of the time. Most of the women in Monclair's books are strong willed and likable. Lily is the opposite. I knew from the previous book that Lily was much more delicate than the rest but not to a childlike degree this book indicates.
I will move on to the next book in the series.

Main Characters were horrible

The whining and bratty behavior made this whole book intolerable! All she did was whine about him not doing everything she wanted on her timetable and then blame him. The gaslighting was horrible and the hero was no better.

Manipulative Lily- Audio book listener

I'm not sure what happened here as I've enjoyed the other books in the series (read out of order) but the combination of a character (Lily), who was so unlikeable, and Paul Woodson's over the top narration made this really difficult to get through.
I'll move ahead to Jake but with a bit more trepidation.

Tone down the "drama" Paul - please

Never again...

Would you try another book from Keira Montclair and/or Paul Woodson?

Yes

Would you ever listen to anything by Keira Montclair again?

Yes

What about Paul Woodson’s performance did you like?

He did a pretty good job considering the weak plot.

What character would you cut from Lily?

Lily?

Any additional comments?

I was hoping the negative reviews about Lily were wrong but I have to agree. My biggest issue with Lily was that she was whiny and still acted like a child instead of a woman grown. Kyle is likable but his weak excuses for not marrying Lily (therefore saving us the CHORE of listening to whiny Lily) and his habit of treating her like a frigging princess. The best parts were the wolves and Logan and Gwyn & their kids....Logan and Gwyn saved yet another book IMO!

Another reviewer mentioned that she felt that the author had a hard time transitioning Lily from a child to a young woman and I think she hit the nail right on the head. I'll never read this one again. Even if I re-read Loki and Torrian; i'll skip this one.

Story 2 (generous)
Narration: 4.5