Country of Ash

A Jewish Doctor in Poland, 1939-1945

De: Edward Reicher, Magda Bogin - translator

Narrado por: Suzanne Toren, Robert Blumenfeld

Duración: 8 h y 15 m

Resumen del Editor

Country of Ash is the starkly compelling, original chronicle of a Jewish doctor who miraculously survived near-certain death, first inside the Lodz and Warsaw ghettoes, where he was forced to treat the Gestapo, then on the Aryan side of Warsaw, where he hid under numerous disguises. He clandestinely recorded the terrible events he witnessed, but his manuscript disappeared during the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. After the war, reunited with his wife and young daughter, he rewrote his story. Peopled with historical figures like the controversial Chaim Rumkowski, who fancied himself a king of the Jews, to infamous Nazi commanders and dozens of Jews and non-Jews who played cat and mouse with death throughout the war, Reicher’s memoir is about a community faced with extinction and the chance decisions and strokes of luck that kept a few stunned souls alive.

©2013 Union des Deportes d’Auschwitz (P)2014 Audible, Inc.

Reseñas de la Crítica

"[Dr. Reicher] lived through the Second World War in Poland, dodging bullets, uprisings,and deportations - to mention betrayal, starvation and airless hideouts in a manner more reminiscent of a talented outlaw than a mild-mannered dermatologist.... It is the impressive simplicity of the good doctor’s writing that makes [t]his book resemble [Victor] Klemperer’s, and the detailed observations of its report that makes it emotionally memorable.... William Carlos Williams once said that people who prize information are perishing daily for want of the information that can be found only in poetry. By the same token, there will never be a time when we will not need the information that an important, evocative book like Country of Ash provides." (Vivian Gornick, Moment magazine)

Narrator was dull and monotone

I have to take points off for the narrator. No expression. The doctors story seems unbelievable at times. Too many near death scenes . Was he just lucky or was God looking out for him.? He was a highly educated man who was greatly disrespected for many years and many people he knew were too His story was so sad but I never got bored. Fast paced and I learned a lot about post war Poland I never knew I came to love his wife. Very strong sensible dedicated wife. Wish I could have meet them both This was truly the greatest generation and yes. God wanted him to stay alive to tell his story

Couldn't stop listening

This tragic story gave a a unique view of life in Warsaw during WW2 for Jewish people. Dr. Reicher was a wonderful and fascinating person. The narration could not have been better!

Excellent

I had family in Poland Jews as well. This is truly a heart wrenching story.
Please read it twice as I did.

Truly amazing story!

If you could sum up Country of Ash in three words, what would they be?

Almost unbelievable!

What did you like best about this story?

Incredible how many times this doctor dodges death. One of the best stories of that horrible time.

What about Suzanne Toren and Robert Blumenfeld ’s performance did you like?

Don't be fooled Suzanne Toren does not narrate this book just the intro. Blumenfelds performance is one of the oddest sometimes funny narrators I've listened to. I almost didn't continue because of it but so glad I did.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

Yes! I kept thinking he'll never escape this one and was awed when he did.

Any additional comments?

Once you get used to narration anyone should love this book. I've listened to many great books about the Holocaust, but this is very different. Totally enjoyable listen, albeit sad as they all are.

This is a very accurate account of the ghetto

A true story is so heartbreaking when you think of the thousands who died and how did this doctor survive ? To think that he testified in court against those nazis !this is amazing !

Story of hard times told in a manner which leaves you with hope in the end.

Good story enjoyed it very much. The story teller spoke in a very fast-pace in which in the beginning annoyed me a bit but I got accustomed to his quick and fast reading of the story. My assumption is that the author also was a quick fast thinking man just by the details of the story. I did quite enjoy a very unenjoyable subject. I would recommend this book.

Riveting if true

This was a fascinating book. I am assuming it was true. Books about the Shoa is very interesting. I have never read one about a Doctor before. Also very few about Poland (Lodz). The protagonist ( the Doctor) is very realistic.

Amazing! Heartbreaking...History

Real living history told through the eyes of an eyewitness.
World War II from the Polish side, from the Jewish Polish side.
Important information for the younger generation to hear.

Was the narrator in a speed contest?

I had to reduce the speed of this book because the narrator was speed-reading.

I did enjoy this book. The doctor's perspective is unique, full of pertinent information about the goings-on of the leaders in the Lodz ghetto.