Constantine’s Sword

The Church and the Jews; A History

De: James Carroll

Narrado por: John Lescault

National Jewish Book Award
National Book Award
New York Times best seller

In a bold and moving book that is sure to spark heated debate, the novelist and cultural critic James Carroll maps the profoundly troubling 2,000-year course of the Church’s battle against Judaism and faces the crisis of faith it has provoked in his own life as a Catholic. More than a chronicle of religion, this dark history is the central tragedy of Western civilization, its fault lines reaching deep into our culture.

The Church’s failure to protest the Holocaust—the infamous “silence” of Pius XII—is only part of the story: the death camps, Carroll shows, are the culmination of a long entrenched tradition of anti-Judaism. From Gospel accounts of the death of Jesus on the cross, to Constantine’s transformation of the cross into a sword, to the rise of blood libels, scapegoating, and modern anti-Semitism, Carroll reconstructs the dramatic story of the Church’s conflict not only with Jews but with itself. Yet in tracing the arc of this narrative, he implicitly affirms that it did not necessarily have to be so. There were roads not taken, heroes forgotten; new roads can be taken yet. Demanding that the Church finally face this past in full, Carroll calls for a fundamental rethinking of the deepest questions of Christian faith. Only then can Christians, Jews, and all who carry the burden of this history begin to forge a new future.

Drawing on his well-known talents as a storyteller and memoirist, and weaving historical research through an intensely personal examination of conscience, Carroll has created a work of singular power and urgency. Constantine’s Sword is a brave and affecting reckoning with difficult truths that will touch every listener.

©2002 James Carroll. For more information, visit JamesCarroll.net (P)2022 Blackstone Publishing

important book

This book is too important to let any minor narration difficulties get in the way of listening to it.
Published in 2001 before books were being read and listened to digitally, I've been hoping for it to come out in audible form for years. I have read parts of the book several times, but it's such a tome, I think I never got all the way through it. I''m happy to start listening to it from the beginning. When they announced it was coming out on Audible, I immediately pre-ordered it.
I was disappointed when they kept postponing the release. They could have had several people read different parts of it and made it go faster.
The narrator has some glitches at the beginning, but I found the book listenable so far.
Carroll's writing is personal and insightful, vulnerable and honest. He faces difficult issues directly, exposing anti-Jewish bias in the history, scripture, and actions of the church, all while maintaining a clear position of love, concern, and respect for this institution he served as a priest.
As a pastor in a main line Protestant denomination, I was concerned that the focus on the Catholic Church would not feel relevant to my experience, but much of the history of the Catholic Church is, of course, the history of all Christian churches. Even the parts of the book that focused on suggestions for a 3rd Vatican council felt relevant and interesting.
I'm only at the beginning of listening to the book this time, but I have listened enough to sense that the narration is not an obstacle to understanding or appreciating the brilliance of this important book.

Listens fine on 1.0x

I just want prospective listeners to know that despite some reviews, this book listens fine as long as you don’t listen to it with any acceleration. It seems like maybe some error related to how the reader pronounces words makes it sound ridiculous when one tries to listen at anything above 1.0 X.

Must-Read for most readers

James Carroll has written a book full of incredibly important and vital information. It’s not just a typical history book that contains a dry litany of Christian crimes against Jews, but instead it examines the philosophies of Christianity and its lies and misinterpretations about Judaism that have given Christians the excuse to hate and persecute Jews for 2000 years. It is part memoir, and a surprisingly honest look at the consequences of the faith he loves. Highly recommended,

A hopeful path to true reconciliation

This book describes how the legacy of Jesus has been used for ill, specifically focusing on how the Catholic Church enacted and implemented an antisemitic theology from early on, the murderous history that has followed up through the Holocaust and how recent efforts to change need to be taken further for true reconciliation to occur. In short, it means emphasizing the revelation of universal love and repudiation of ideas about salvation, trading the singular centrality of a death blamed on all Jews for a truly ecumenical embracing of all people and faiths in the light of connected and at times inscrutable existence where love is a marvelous path toward joy and meaning and an able response to challenges.

Brilliant book, terrible narration

This is an absolutely brilliant book. Well researched and well written. It’s an important book. I wish everyone would read it. (In full disclosure I am a James Carroll fan already.)
When I say, “I wish everyone would read it,” I mean everyone except the narrator! This honestly sounds like audible took a million snippets of the narrator’s voice and then spliced them together making this sound like an odd, automated, computer “reading” the book. It’s so distracting that (to me) it is unlistenable!
To be clear, I strongly recommend the book, just not this audio version.

Horrific narration of an fine work

It would be better to have a robot read this than the man who unfortunately does it. This is an important work and I’m disgusted that this man read this.

Great book, poor performance

Should be required reading for anyone who calls themselves a Christian. Unfortunately, the performance sounds like a cross between Siri and William Shatner.

Narration is nearly impossible to tolerate

The author narrates this book- a huge mistake. Huge. The story is so good, his non- speaking voice so intelligent. I listened to five hours of this and finally realized that every time I listened to this narrator’s robotic, at best Christopher walkenesque reading of his own material, I had to stop because I had a migraine. The absolute worst narration I’ve encountered on audible. Too bad. I have a headache now- argh!

A Masterpiece of Research

Firstly I’d like to discuss the issue of narration. Initially, I also found that the narration sounded computer generated an impossible to listen to. That was until I discovered that the default speed was 1.3 times normal speed. I have brought this to the attention of Audible and hopefully this has been corrected. The narration is perfectly acceptable at 1.0 speed.

This is one of the most impressive books that I have ever read or listen to. The honesty, the courage the pathos, the vulnerability, and the love of the author is monumental. The research that must have gone into this book is monumental. Although I can imagine that actually reading such a book maybe difficult, I’m delighted that it came out in an audible form so that we can benefit from it.
The suffering for almost 2000 years brought about by the vilification of Judaism and Jews by the Catholic Church knows no bounds. It sheds a clear light on the origins of the rampant antisemitism that we are experiencing in the world today, and if this scourge is to stop, this book needs to be studied and taken very seriously by both Jews and Christians alike.

I note that among the keywords relating to this book, Audible has included Judaism, history, religious intolerance and holocaust but his failed to site Catholicism as a keyword, which is strange as this is essentially what the entire book is about.

I recommend this book as a “must read” for everyone since the hatred in the world simply has to stop.

Author Reinforces His Own Beliefs

The author is a catholic centrist who believes the failure of the Church is that it is not liberal enough. The monumental failure of the institution to which he has attached himself never seems to have made him reconsider his preconceived notions on a material level.