Brilliant Blunders

From Darwin to Einstein - Colossal Mistakes by Great Scientists That Changed Our Understanding of Life and the Universe

De: Mario Livio

Narrado por: Jeff Cummings

We all make mistakes. Nobody’s perfect. Not even some of the greatest geniuses in history, as Mario Livio tells us in this marvelous story of scientific error and breakthrough.

Charles Darwin, William Thomson (Lord Kelvin), Linus Pauling, Fred Hoyle, and Albert Einstein were all brilliant scientists. Each made groundbreaking contributions to his field - but each also stumbled badly. Darwin’s theory of natural selection shouldn’t have worked, according to the prevailing beliefs of his time. Not until Gregor Mendel’s work was known would there be a mechanism to explain natural selection. How could Darwin be both wrong and right? Lord Kelvin, Britain’s leading scientific intellect at the time, gravely miscalculated the age of the Earth. Linus Pauling, the world’s premier chemist (who would win the Nobel Prize in chemistry) constructed an erroneous model for DNA in his haste to beat the competition to publication. Astrophysicist Fred Hoyle dismissed the idea of a "Big Bang" origin to the universe (ironically, the caustic name he gave to this event endured long after his erroneous objections were disproven). And Albert Einstein, whose name is synonymous with genius, speculated incorrectly about the forces that hold the universe in equilibrium - and that speculation opened the door to brilliant conceptual leaps.

These five scientists expanded our knowledge of life on Earth, the evolution of the Earth itself, and the evolution of the universe, despite and because of their errors. As Mario Livio luminously explains, the scientific process advances through error. Mistakes are essential to progress.

Brilliant Blunders is a singular tour through the world of science and scientific achievement - and a wonderfully insightful examination of the psychology of five fascinating scientists.

©2013 Marie Livio (P)2013 Brilliance Audio, Inc.

Very complete and different perspective on genius

Very interesting perspective on science and human mindset, showing even genius make mistakes as we do.

Fascinatingly dry as an overcooked Turkey.

Is there anything you would change about this book?

I'd start with Einstein and cosmology and finish with Darwin.

What do you think your next listen will be?

The Mezzanine by Nicholson Baker

What about Jeff Cummings’s performance did you like?

I didn't find anything to dislike.

Did Brilliant Blunders inspire you to do anything?

It inspired me to make a salami and cheese sandwich while listening. Does that count?

Any additional comments?

It's a good book and fascinating subject, but brother does it need gravy.

Blunder Bust

The history of science aspects of this book are quite interesting but the incidents are tied together primarily by the somewhat odd concept of blunders thus seemed to me scattered and lacking the focus of a great history of science. I was not convinced by the author’s main point nor his distinction between good, but mistaken, science versus a scientific blunder. The author spends time demonstrating it was unlikely that Einstein actually said including the cosmological constant in general relativity was a blunder. The problem is I really didn’t care if Einstein actually said it was a blunder or not (and I still don’t know anyway). The author comments personally on the priority of some scientific claims (for example Lemaitre vs Hubble), that I felt were distracting at best. The author’s language was repeatedly sloppy. He throws around terms like “right” and “wrong” and “true” but points out elsewhere that science is not about these words. I have read more incisive histories of science and was familiar with almost all the science history presented here, and I did not find the history rehash enlightening nor the thesis compelling.

This is not at all a bad book. I just really like the histories of science and this one seemed less penetrating and less compelling than the best.

Loved this book!

I read a lot of history and science, but this book told me about many things I never knew. I liked the progression of the topics, the background information setting the stage for each scientist and the explanation of the subject. It was a perfect balance. I listened to this on a 10 hour drive and I barely noticed the time passing by!

Blunder no more

Well written dive into some of the history of science - worth your time. One point that is salient to me is that the examples given are not really "blunders" - I have to assume that this word was chosen to be provocative. To the contrary of American media, which depicts scientists and/or generally brilliant people as being able to make effortless correct leaps that immediately drive the progress of technology and/or understanding, this book does a great job showing that even the most respected and lauded scientists worked very hard, often to only take one small step forward, and were still blindly searching with much guesswork. Not surprisingly, they made mistakes or were unable to fill in certain gaps to their theories, but other scientists used these as opportunities for further progress our understanding.

Illuminating Book - Annoying Read

Can't imagine how Dr. Mario Livio finds the bandwidth to bust out book after book of consistently high quality. "Brilliant Blunders" dives deep into details surrounding discoveries without loosing sight of its theme of intellectual bravery.

Narrator Jeff Cummings is competent and has a fine instrument but was clearly misdirected. There are many incorrect and under-researched mispronunciations. Most troubling was the choice to speak quotations in affected and code-switched ethnic accents. These just don't work and detract seriously from the thread of story. The producers should have spent the money to hire sp

A fresh and brilliant look at history

I can imagine that the inspiration for this book came from the well known saying attributed to Einstein, who reportedly claimed the cosmological constant as his biggest blunder (there's a surprise in this regard in the book). What other famous scientists committed blunders that may have been no blunders at all - or that inspired others to brilliance? The book answes this question in a magnificent manner, bringing to life the well known stories of the discovery of the theory of evolution, of the age of the Earth and the Sun, of the structure of the DNA, of the early origins of the Universe and of the general theory of relativity. It takes a fresh and sometimes surprising look at these stories, focusing on the mishaps rather than successes, and analyzing these mishaps in minute detail, but in an extremely engaging way. The reading is also well done - for the most part I even loved the various accents and affectations attempted by the reader in order to represent the characters.

Audible Blunders

What does Jeff Cummings bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

Jeff Cummings often blunders in his pronunciations of both scientific words such as helical, and of the names of many well known scientists.

A wonderful trip through modern science

This is a wonderful complement to "Farewell to Reality". Both books are written by fully rounded and grounded scientists. Both are full of insights and highlight the human dimension of the science industry. This title builds the history and backdrop on the intellectual and social levels describing the achievements of modern science that we often take for granted and think they were always there for everyone.

Science by Humans

I feel smarter for having listened to this. Wonderfully explained concepts that have previously flown over my head, put into enjoyably human context.