The Rise of Job Hugging: Nonprofit Hiring Challenge

Send us Fan Mail

Nonprofit hiring challenges in 2026 are shifting in unexpected ways—and it’s not about a lack of talent. It’s about behavior. In this episode, we explore how “job hugging” is reshaping the nonprofit workforce and slowing hiring across the sector.

Dana Scurlock, Managing Director at Staffing Boutique, breaks down a growing trend where nonprofit professionals are choosing stability over opportunity. Rather than pursuing new roles or promotions, many are holding tightly to their current positions due to uncertainty in funding, policy changes, and broader economic pressures.

As Dana explains, “It’s not for lack of candidates—it’s for lack of candidate interest in moving jobs.” This shift has major implications for nonprofit leaders trying to fill roles, build teams, and drive innovation.

The result? Hiring pipelines are shrinking, searches are taking longer, and organizations are competing harder for fewer willing candidates. Even when strong candidates exist, they must be “courted” out of stable roles—raising the stakes for hiring processes and organizational reputation.

But the impact goes deeper. Job hugging isn’t just slowing hiring—it’s also affecting internal culture. Reduced mobility, fewer promotions, and fear-driven decision-making can limit innovation and stall organizational progress.

Dana also highlights a critical shift in candidate priorities: “More than anything, candidates want to be somewhere stable where they can grow and be set up for success.” For nonprofit leaders, this means rethinking how roles are positioned, how hiring is conducted, and how stability is communicated.

If your organization is struggling to fill roles, retain talent, or maintain momentum, this conversation offers practical insight into what’s really happening—and what you can do about it.

00:00:00 Introduction to Job Hugging
00:01:10 What Is Job Hugging?
00:03:30 Why the Nonprofit Job Market Is Shifting
00:06:40 How Uncertainty Impacts Career Decisions
00:09:10 Why Hiring Pipelines Are Slowing Down
00:12:00 Internal Job Hugging and Career Stagnation
00:14:50 Impact on Innovation and Organizational Growth
00:17:10 What Nonprofits Should Watch For
00:19:00 What Candidates Want Now: Stability Over Salary
00:21:30 Risk Aversion and Workforce Behavior
00:24:00 How Long Will This Trend Last?
00:25:40 What Leaders Can Do Right Now

#TheNonprofitShow #Nonprofitmanagement #NonprofitHiring

Find us Live daily on YouTube!

Find us Live daily on LinkedIn!

Find us Live daily on X: @Nonprofit_Show

Our national co-hosts and amazing guests discuss management, money and missions of nonprofits!
12:30pm ET 11:30am CT 10:30am MT 9:30am PT

Send us your ideas for Show Guests or Topics: [e-mail]
Visit us on the web:The Nonprofit Show