#629 Daughter Pregnant at 15. What Would You Do?

On today’s podcast, Niall is joined by journalist Fatima Gunning from Gript Media to discuss a deeply sensitive and divisive situation sent in by a listener.

A mother has contacted the show after discovering that her 15-year-old daughter is pregnant by her 17-year-old boyfriend. While the young couple have reportedly been together for two years, the parents are now sharply divided on what to do next. The father believes the only responsible course of action is to go to the Gardaí and report the boyfriend. The mother strongly disagrees, fearing that involving the authorities could alienate their daughter, fracture the family, and ultimately do more harm than good. She believes the boyfriend intends to stand by their daughter and that the family must now face the reality of the situation together.

With legal, moral, and emotional questions colliding, Niall and Fatima examine the complexities of consent, age of responsibility, parental duty, and the unintended consequences of involving the criminal justice system in a family crisis.

Listeners then join the conversation live, offering mixed and often conflicting views on what the father should do — from those who say the law must be followed regardless, to others who argue that compassion, trust, and keeping the family together should come first.

What would you do?

Would you report the boyfriend — or handle it within the family?

A difficult conversation, with no easy answers.