Betrayal of Command | Asad Khan - S.O.S. #252

Send us a text

A Marine officer who helped open Pakistan’s gateway to Afghanistan, coordinated CSAR basing, and carried the keys to a shuttered Kabul embassy steps into the studio to talk about combat, command, and the price of telling the truth. We walk through the early days after 9/11—commercial flights into Rawalpindi with a rucksack full of radios, late-night negotiations for overflight and basing, and the scramble to build humane, lawful processes as refugees surged and detainee operations strained capacity. Then we move to the mountains, where a lean battalion landing team rewrote SOPs, trained NCOs from scratch, welded armor onto Humvees, and led local militias with a blend of trust and hard boundaries. The outcomes were stark: historic enemy losses, zero fratricide, and a unit that fought for months on grit and discipline.

What makes this story different isn’t just the firefights—it’s the candor about strategy and culture. We question whether invasion was the only path to bin Laden, explore how local networks and precise incentives could have achieved ends without buying the whole country, and detail the cost of confusing occupation with victory. We also pull back the curtain on headquarters-versus-field dynamics: pressure to bomb without positive ID, awards gaming, and media optics that overshadowed months of deprivation and risk. When investigations arrived over “harsh language,” the larger lesson became impossible to ignore: institutions often reward silence and punish truth, even when results in the field are undeniable.

The conversation is a field manual for moral courage. We talk practical leadership—how to train under time pressure, protect your people when gear is lacking, verify local intel, and hold a diverse, uneasy coalition together under ROE. And we talk accountability—why double standards around fratricide and promotions corrode trust, and how honest after-action reviews save lives. If you care about Afghanistan war lessons, military leadership accountability, civil-military trust, and the ethics of command, this is a rare, unfiltered look from someone who was there, who kept receipts, and who still believes we can get better.

If this resonated, subscribe, share with a friend, and leave a review. Your feedback helps more listeners find thoughtful,

Support the show

Visit my website: https://thehello.llc/THERESACARPENTER
Read my writings on my blog: https://www.theresatapestries.com/
Listen to other episodes on my podcast: https://storiesofservice.buzzsprout.com
Watch episodes of my podcast:
https://www.youtube.com/c/TheresaCarpenter76