Identity, Exile and the Illusion of Safety: Fr David Neuhaus SJ and the Prophetic Imagination in the Holy Land

This episode was released after a period of pause following the Bondi attack, as we grieved in solidarity with our Jewish brothers and sisters. In the final episode of In the Shadows of the Holy Land, we speak with Fr David Neuhaus SJ, an Israeli Jesuit priest, theologian, and one of the most important voices in Jewish–Christian relations in the region.

Born into a Jewish family shaped by exile and the trauma of the Holocaust, raised in apartheid-era South Africa, and later received into the Catholic Church, Fr David’s life has unfolded across some of the defining moral crises of the modern world. That journey has given him a way of seeing the Holy Land from the margins.

In this conversation, Fr David reflects on identity and belonging, the legacy of 1917 and the modern roots of the conflict, the misuse of Scripture in Zionism and Christian Zionism, and the dangerous illusion that security can be built on domination and exclusion. He speaks candidly about anti-Semitism, its reality, its horror, and its weaponisation, and about the Church’s struggle to speak clearly in the face of injustice.

Drawing on theology, history, and personal encounter, this episode wrestles with what it means to be prophetic in a time of war, how lament is not a failure of faith, and where fragile but real signs of hope might still be found.