Stars Forward Grades + Robertson’s Ask & Dumba Deal | Episode 6128 | July 16th, 2025

Ryan and Chris hand out final grades for every Dallas Stars forward in the 2024–25 season — and let’s just say some of these report cards got messy. From Mikko Rantanen’s playoff heroics to Matt Duchene’s postseason disappearance, the guys break down who showed up, who didn’t, and what it all means heading into 2025–26.

Other hot topics:

• Is Jason Robertson really worth $12M per year?

• Why Rope Hintz and Wyatt Johnston still haven’t unlocked their full potential

• Jim Nill’s cleanup of the Dumba deal — smart move or expensive mistake?

• Stars’ insane 2025–26 schedule breakdown

• The Sam Steel Top 6 experiment (???)

Plus, Granlund nostalgia, Jamie Benn's regression, and a brief Stars Fan Stories shoutout.

💬 New Stars' Fan Stories episodes premiere every Tuesday at 7 pm on our YouTube channel throughout the months of July and August! Available on audio platforms the following Wednesday!
Subscribe and follow us to hear more incredible Stars fan stories all summer long!

We're Looking for sponsors! If you or your business want to partner with a passionate, growing hockey podcast with a loyal Dallas Stars fanbase, we’d love to connect. Check out our media kit by clicking here to learn how you can support Starcastic Remarks and reach a dedicated NHL audience. JOIN THE Who CARES Club! Love Starcastic Remarks? Join our membership club, The Who Cares Club! For $5/month, you get some exclusive perks and help the most sarcastic Stars podcast continue to grow and continue on! Click here to join! Support Starcastic Remarks! Help us grow by leaving a 5-star review wherever you listen to podcasts—it makes a huge difference! Watch us on YouTube and click like & subscribe and hit that notification bell! Follow us across social media for updates, highlights, and behind-the-scenes content:

• YouTube: @StarcasticR
• Twitter (X): @StarcasticR
• Discord: Join Here
• TikTok: @StarcasticR
• Instagram: @StarcasticR
• Facebook: @StarcasticR

Visit our website here for more content!