Episode 337 - Reunion! Sandmeyer, Stretch & Mitch Together for 1st Time in 20 Years

RUNDOWN

Mitch kicks off Episode 337 with a deceptively tough trivia question about Louisiana’s top-selling music artist—hint: it’s not the one you’d expect. That sets the tone for a packed show that includes a heated Mariners No-Table debate over Randy Johnson’s Mariners legacy and whether Seattle ever truly embraced one of the game’s greats. Mariners No-Table, with Joe Doyle (Future Stars Series) and Brady Farkas (MLB analyst & podcaster) tackle the club’s shaky offense, trade deadline outlook, and whether the front office is bold enough to make a real playoff push.

It’s a nostalgic and energetic ride as Mitch reunites with the original KJR Sports Pit crew — Jason Puckett, Steve Sandmeyer, and Matt Johnson — for a three-part conversation packed with inside stories, on-air memories, and raw reflections on their time together. From launching an iconic Seattle sports segment to the challenges of keeping it alive, the guys share hilarious behind-the-scenes tales and openly discuss the circumstances that led to its sudden end. It’s equal parts reunion, therapy session, and roast — and a rare glimpse into what made Seattle radio tick in the 2000s.

GUESTS

Joe Doyle | MLB Draft Analyst, OverSlot, Future Stars Series and Mariners Reporter

Brady Farkas | Sports Radio Host and Mariners contributor

Jason Puckett | Former KJR Sports Radio Host and Co-Host of The Sports Pit

Steve Sandmeyer | Former KJR Host and Producer of The Sports Pit

Matt “Stretch” Johnson | Longtime Seattle Sports Radio Personality

TABLE OF CONTENTS

0:00 | Mitch quizzes Hotshot Scott on the top-selling artist from Louisiana (spoiler: Britney Spears), sparking a playful debate over musical icons and surprising stats. The duo sets the stage for a nostalgic Sports Pit reunion and previews the lineup of longtime Seattle sports voices.

27:56 | Joe Doyle (Future Stars Series) and Brady Farkas (MLB Insider) join Mitch to dissect the Mariners’ recent struggles, pitching rotation inconsistencies, and potential trade deadline moves. The trio debates whether Seattle should buy or sell, how injuries have altered the outlook, and what front office boldness might mean for a playoff push.

55:11 | Jason Puckett and Steve Sandmeyer kick off the Sports Pit reunion with Mitch, revisiting their early days on KJR, behind-the-scenes dynamics, and the unique blend of chaos and chemistry that made the show a Seattle favorite. They reflect on their friendship, battles with management, and the show's surprising influence.

1:25:44 | Mitch, Sandmeyer, and Puckett dive deeper into the Sports Pit era, exploring its impact on Seattle sports media and the authenticity that drew a loyal following. They share personal moments, fan memories, and address how the show would—or wouldn’t—work today. A candid look at the evolution of sports radio through the lens of their pioneering chaos.

1:59:21 | The Sports Pit trio closes out their reunion with reflections on life after KJR, including career updates and personal growth. They share final laughs, rapid-fire memories, and emotional gratitude for the listeners who made it all matter. A fitting end to a heartfelt and hilarious throwback.

2:26:38 | In “The Other Stuff,” Mitch and Hotshot cover a wild mix of headlines: a British Airways attendant caught dancing naked mid-flight, Derrick Henry’s movie bet with Adam Sandler, John Olerud’s $65k tree feud, and Sean Kemp’s court plea. They spotlight Coco Gauff’s classy French Open win and Sabalenka’s poor sportsmanship, Paul Skenes’ historic ERA start, and Livvy Dunne’s creepy autograph seekers. Plus, Saquon Barkley lands the Madden cover, a coach’s slur controversy, and a roundup of RIPs including Rick Derringer and Loretta Swit.